A federal judge has rejected attempts by a former Army Ranger charged in the Capitol riot to get parts of his case dismissed as his trial approaches in the District of Columbia.
U.S. District Judge Trevor McFadden on Wednesday ruled against Robert Morss and three other men who will be tried with him on charges of storming the Capitol and assaulting police in support of Donald Trump's repeated lies about the 2020 election.
Mr. Morss, 29, an Afghanistan combat veteran from Glenshaw, faces a lengthy prison term if convicted on numerous felony counts. Prosecutors say he was a leader and an instigator of the riot.
In motions to dismiss, he and his accused cohorts wanted the judge to throw out a charge of obstruction of an official proceeding.
Their main argument is that the certification of the Electoral College was "merely ceremonial" and not an official proceeding. Judge McFadden said he and other judges in the district have already rejected that contention in other Jan. 6 cases, with one exception, and he won't change his mind on this one without any basis. He said the Electoral College certification of Joe Biden's victory was indeed an official proceeding as defined by federal law.
"Defendants give no reason for the Court to reconsider its prior ruling or to go against the consensus in this district," the judge said.
Read More
He also rejected several other arguments on the obstruction issue, including one often repeated by other Capitol rioters that the obstruction charge is “unconstitutionally vague.”
Mr. Morss and the others also challenged the civil disorder counts they face, saying the language of the statute is vague and overly broad in violation of free expression conduct covered by the First Amendment.
Judge McFadden said again that other judges have already rejected that argument and he will too.
In another challenge, the defendants said counts of disorderly or violent conduct in a restricted building — the Capitol — should be thrown out. A restricted building under the law is defined as one where a person protected by the Secret Service "is or will be temporarily visiting." Prosecutors say Mike Pence, the vice president, was temporarily visiting on Jan. 6 to certify Biden's win.
But Mr. Morss and the other rioters say Pence cannot "temporarily" visit the Capitol because he had an office there and was "simply going to work" on Jan. 6. They also said that if the idea of temporarily visiting is ambiguous or unclear in the statute, the judge should apply what's called the rule of lenity, which means he should interpret the law in a way most favorable to the defendants.
Judge McFadden said the defendants can raise that issue at trial if they choose, but he won’t dismiss the count now. He said again that every other judge in DC has rejected that same argument.
Ms. Morss faces 53 counts in all and will be tried along with Patrick McCaughey of Connecticut, Tristan Stevens of Florida, and David Mehaffie of Ohio.
Mr. Morss served three tours in Afghanistan and then worked briefly as a substitute teacher in the Shaler Area district.
He is among some two dozen people from the Western District of Pennsylvania and nearby regions accused of storming the Capitol in response to Mr. Trump's call to action.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.