Lawyers for accused synagogue shooter Robert Bowers have asked the judge in his capital case not to qualify the jury for the death penalty.
In a motion to bar death qualification, the defense team says the process of picking the jury will end up eliminating anyone who opposes capital punishment, such as Black people, Hispanics, women and members of religious groups.
Bowers is accused in federal court of killing 11 worshippers at Tree of Life in October 2018. The Justice Department is seeking death, although President Joe Biden has said publicly that he opposes the death penalty. Bowers’ lawyers want a plea deal for life in prison. A potential trial could happen in the spring of 2023 but no date has been set.
The parties have been sparring over the death penalty for three years.
In the latest attempt by the defense to spare Bowers’ life, his lawyers say that excluding everyone who opposes the death penalty, but is able to be fair during the guilt phase of a trial, “will produce a jury that is biased in favor of conviction and death.”
The lawyers argue that juries in capital cases are more likely to be older, white, Protestant and less educated than other criminal juries.
Read More
The defense cites various researchers who, they say, have concluded that juries with lots of white men are more biased in favor of death than juries with fewer white men or in cases with a white defendant.
“The results of the research are relevant to understanding the significance of the risk that if Mr. Bowers’ jury is death qualified, racial discrimination will improperly influence the outcome of the trial,” the lawyers said.
In every other criminal trial, they said the court creates a “firewall” between the jurors and any consideration of a sentence. But a death qualification, they said, means the jurors will be required to consider it and will be biased in favor of it.
They also said qualifying the jury for the death penalty will improperly influence the jury’s decisions in the guilt phase of the trial.
The prosecution will now have a chance to respond and U.S. District Judge Robert Colville will decide.
The defense has already lost an attempt to get the death penalty tossed. They had argued that the Federal Death Penalty Act violates the Constitution. But in 2020, U.S. District Judge Donetta Ambrose, who has since retired, said it does not and allowed the case to proceed.
Colville, who took over for Ambrose, said last month that he anticipates a trial in about a year from now.
A possible date could be set at an Aug. 15 conference between the parties.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.