A federal judge in Denver has ruled against former Greensburg dentist Lawrence Rudolph and his mistress, Lori Milliron, in rejecting their attempts to keep some government evidence out of their upcoming murder trial.

Mr. Rudolph is accused of shooting his wife Bianca with a shotgun during a 2016 African safari and staging it as an accident so he could collect on insurance and live together in Phoenix with Ms. Milliron, his former office manager.

The trial is set to start July 11.

U.S. District Judge William Martinez this week said the government will be allowed to present photos of Mr. Rudolph's wife posing with slain big-game animals in Africa, along with statements Bianca allegedly made to a friend that Mr. Rudolph might try to kill her and evidence that Ms. Milliron bought propofol for Mr. Rudolph to take with him to Africa as another means to kill Bianca.

Advertise with us

Lawyers for Mr. Rudolph and Ms. Milliron had filed motions to exclude those pieces of evidence and others ahead of the trial.

Mr. Rudolph, 67, who had run Three Rivers Dental Group, is charged with murdering his wife and collecting $4.8 million in life insurance. Ms. Milliron is accused of lying to a grand jury in covering up their affair and the killing.

Read More

Mr. Rudolph had wanted to bar prosecutors from showing the jury pictures of Bianca with dead animals. He and his lawyer said the pictures don't prove Bianca was adept as a hunter. That's important to them because their argument is that Bianca accidentally shot herself while packing away her shotgun.

The government countered that the pictures should be included because they show she was familiar with guns, making an accident less likely.

The judge agreed with the government and said the pictures will be part of the case.

Advertise with us

Mr. Rudolph also wanted to bar any "expert" testimony of Otto Westhassel, the former consular chief at the U.S. embassy in Lusaka and a former Marine who, suspicious of Mr. Rudolph, visited the African funeral home where Bianca's body was kept and said her wound was consistent with a shotgun blast from 10 meters.

Mr. Rudolph and his lawyer said Mr. Westhassel should not be allowed to render an opinion about the wound as any kind of expert.

The U.S. attorney's office maintained that he will testify only as a witness who saw the body but not as an expert. The judge sided with the defense and said he will hold the government to that promise, leaving the wound analysis to medical and ballistics experts.

But the judge sided with the government on the inclusion of testimony from another witness, Cassandra Olmstead, about what Bianca had told her shortly before her death.

Ms. Olmstead said Bianca had told her that she was afraid of divorcing Mr. Rudolph because she couldn't take care of herself and was afraid of losing her children. Ms. Olmstead said Bianca also told her she had given her husband an ultimatum about ending his affair with Ms. Milliron and that she feared Mr. Rudolph might try to murder her during their African safari but went anyway to try to save her marriage.

Advertise with us

Mr. Rudolph's lawyer said those statements should be tossed as hearsay.

But the government argued that the comments need to be taken in the context of allegations from Mr. Rudolph's friends that he had been abusing his position as an officer in their hunting club to carry on affairs. As a result, he had sued them for defamation and he faced the possibility that Bianca would testify against him in that case and in a possible divorce proceeding.

The government also said it will introduce Ms. Olmstead only after prosecutors have presented their other evidence to show that Mr. Rudolph murdered Bianca.

Judge Martinez said he'd allow the testimony but would let Mr. Rudolph and his lawyer raise an objection at trial before she gets on the stand.

The government has also indicated it has additional evidence against Ms. Milliron that she committed healthcare fraud at the dental practice and arson at her former residence in 2010. Prosecutors said they won't use the healthcare fraud allegations unless Mr. Rudolph argues at trial about the high value of his dental practice, and they indicated they won't introduce the arson evidence. Judge Martinez said he would hold the government to those assertions.

Advertise with us

Ms. Milliron and Mr. Rudolph lost on another matter involving propofol, which the government maintains was Mr. Rudolph's Plan B in his plot to kill Bianca.

A Three Rivers Dental employee, Sherry Houk, said that she bought propofol, an anesthetic, for Mr. Rudolph at Ms. Milliron's request around the time of Bianca's death.

The defense said that introducing that evidence is unfair and will confuse the jury.

Propofol causes loss of consciousness and in high doses can kill. Prosecutors said that Mr. Rudolph took the drug with him to Africa as "an additional murder weapon." They said its purchase is relevant to show premeditation on Mr. Rudolph’s part and Ms. Milliron's knowledge of that premeditation before she testified before the grand jury early this year.

"Based on the government’s detailed description of the witness’ forthcoming testimony regarding the unusual procurement of propofol for Rudolph through Milliron, as well as the timing of such procurement, the court concludes that such evidence is relevant to the charges against Milliron and will not exclude this evidence," the judge ruled.

Advertise with us

He also said the propofol evidence won't confuse the jury.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com