Donald Trump supporter Jennifer Heinl of Ross said Wednesday that she breached the U.S. Capitol to find shelter from the chaos outside, but a sentencing judge didn't buy it and sentenced her to jail for two weeks along with two years of probation.

"What you're saying is, 'I broke the law to protect myself,'" said U.S. District Judge Emmet Sullivan in Washington, D.C. "You understand how that's difficult to understand?"

Heinl had a hard time explaining why, if she was so scared, she is seen on video high-fiving someone and smiling as she walked into the Capitol with the pro-Trump mob on Jan. 6, 2021.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Maria Fedor said Heinl's mood was "celebratory," not fearful.

Advertise with us

The judge agreed.

"What about that smile?" he asked her.

Heinl said she didn't remember smiling but said she smiles when she's anxious.

In the end, the judge said he didn't believe she was trying to protect herself.

"I just reject that as a rational explanation," he said, describing the insurrection she joined as "an attack on democracy."

Advertise with us

Heinl, the wife of a Shaler police officer who serves on an FBI task force, is among some two dozen people from the Pittsburgh region who stormed the Capitol in support of Trump's false election fraud claims. No evidence has emerged to bolster the contention that the election was stolen and even Trump’s former attorney general, William Barr, has said it is not true.

Heinl’s sentencing came the day before a House committee investigating the Capitol breach holds its first public hearing on Thursday.

Judge Sullivan said Heinl’s probation will start now and she can serve her 14 days in jail in September. He also ordered her to do 50 hours of community service and pay $500 in restitution.

She argued for probation and no jail, saying she's a good person who made a bad choice.

"I made the decision because the outside was so chaotic," she said, describing how police and rioters were skirmishing amid tear gas clouds and the explosions of flash bang grenades.

Advertise with us

"Why didn't you just run the other way?" Judge Sullivan asked her.

"There was nowhere to go," she said.

Ms. Fedor said that wasn't true; video of her outside the building shows no one around her.

Heinl had previously pleaded guilty to demonstrating in a Capitol building, a misdemeanor. She spent 47 minutes wandering around inside, then later lied to the FBI.

She had entered the Capitol with Kenneth Grayson of Bridgeville. Her lawyer, Marty Dietz, said she had known him years before but they hadn’t seen each other in a long time. The two did not travel together and happened to run into each other at the riot, he said.

Advertise with us

He said she didn't do anything violent or encourage other rioters but entered the building because it was the "path of least resistance."

Mr. Dietz said it was the "worst decision of her life" and cost her a good job, her marriage and many friendships back home, since he said no one wants to associate with her anymore.

Mr. Dietz asked for leniency, saying Heinl has never been in trouble with the law before and takes care of two sons with health problems.

The judge said he thinks Heinl is a good person and a good mother but still deserves some jail time. After he sentenced her, he wished her well and said he hopes she'll come back to Washington sometime to visit - this time peacefully.

The case against Grayson is pending.