The former owner of three Citi Tax stores in the Pittsburgh area who defrauded the government of $7.2 million cried before a judge Tuesday and asked for probation, saying he's worked hard his whole life since coming to the U.S. from Ethiopia in 1991 and provides for 50 family members.
But U.S. District Judge Marilyn Horan rejected the request and sent him to federal prison for three years.
The judge imposed that term on Ephrem Lijalem, 48, who had pleaded guilty to aiding in preparing thousands of false income tax returns.
Lijalem ran Citi Tax Refund stores in Pittsburgh, Penn Hills and McKeesport. He and multiple tax preparers who worked for him, all of whom also pleaded guilty, filed more than 6,000 fraudulent returns for clients from 2010 to 2016.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Greg Melucci said Lijalem's stores falsified Schedule C attachments for profits or losses from businesses. In some cases, those businesses didn't exist; in others, the preparers inflated income or altered expenses to maximize refunds.
The scheme cost the U.S. $7.2 million, according to the criminal investigation division of the IRS.
Judge Horan said Lijalem will have to pay that money back.
Lijalem said he came to the U.S. to realize the American dream and worked many low-wage jobs before buying into the local Citi Tax franchises.
He and his St. Louis lawyer, Greg Bailey, said Lijalem has long sent money home to his extended family in Ethiopia and used the rest to support his wife and four boys in America.
Lijalem admitted that what he did was "greedy" but asked that he not go to prison, saying he runs a profitable trucking business now in Illinois.
But Mr. Melucci said Lijalem deserved to go to prison. Lijalem, Mr. Melucci said, ripped off the very country that gave him his opportunity as an immigrant.
In addition, Lijalem had many chances to stop breaking the law but didn't.
Long before he was charged, the IRS had warned him about what he was doing and at one point fined him. In 2013, the U.S. Department of Justice also filed a permanent injunction against him for filing bogus returns, gouging customers with high fees and forging names.
None of that stopped him.
Mr. Melucci said Lijalem recruited preparers to solicit business from poor people or those with little experience filing taxes. He hired preparers with no experience and offered them $100 per return to file false Schedule C attachments.
And while Mr. Bailey argued that Lijalem didn't personally benefit from the $7.2 million in fraudulent refunds the scheme generated, Mr. Melucci said Lijalem did profit by nailing his customers with exorbitant fees.
The judge agreed that Lijalem is not deserving of probation.
"You were aware of [the fraud]. You knew what was going on," she told him.
She let Lijalem self-report to federal prison and said she'd recommend somewhere in the Midwest near his new home, although the Bureau of Prisons will make the final decision.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.