Evidence suggests sentimental value was more important than money to a Squirrel Hill man accused of stealing hundreds of religious items from the local Jewish community.
When police searched Andrew Clinton’s home last week, they found over 300 objects they believe he burglarized from community members, stores and rabbis as part of a yearslong accumulation of personal and religious possessions.
The alleged crimes were more than petty theft; police allege they were part of a complex series of ruses and lies that Mr. Clinton used to endear himself to victims before swindling them out of Judaica, books, portraits and religious relics.
“It’s crazy,” said Detective Francesco Rosato, who’s investigating the case for Pittsburgh police. “It’s kind of scary, because the Jewish population — especially the older synagogue congregations — they’re older, easily victimized. He knew that.”

But Mr. Clinton didn’t just trick the type of people who are easily fooled, Detective Rosato said. He was cunning enough to embed himself into the lives of knowledgeable and experienced religious leaders, fully convincing them that he was an enterprising rabbinical student with a deep connection to the faith, despite the fact that he wasn’t Jewish and didn’t seem to have made any efforts to convert.
Police are still searching for many of the alleged victims, with only about a dozen of them currently identified, as well as other pieces of potential evidence.
Read More
“The folks that we began speaking to, who are victims, all said the exact same thing: That he knew and embraced the religion, and he knew so much about it that he was able to converse with 70-year-old rabbis that had known the theology back and forth,” Detective Rosato said.
“He could converse, and actually they respected it to the point where he was able to get into synagogues and become a member of synagogues.”
Mr. Clinton, 20, was arrested by Allegheny County police on April 5 in connection to an alleged string of home burglaries that spanned the area, using similar methods in Fox Chapel, O’Hara and Squirrel Hill.
He was arrested on more than a dozen charges, including burglary, criminal attempt burglary, theft, receiving stolen property and criminal mischief. He is still in the Allegheny County Jail on a $20,000 bail, according to court records.
Joseph Pometto, the attorney defending Mr. Clinton, emphasized that all defendants are innocent until proven guilty.
“I hope to resolve this case in a way that is satisfying to all parties involved,” he said.
Police said the investigation is only beginning, as they attempt to unravel the myriad of scams Mr. Clinton is accused of pulling, some of which date back to 2018.
Detective Rosato described the patterns as those of a pathological liar who had genuine appreciation for Judaism, saying the man was charming enough to fully enter the lives of faith leaders, families and community stalwarts.
He also allegedly presented himself as a home improvement and general contractor, as well as a landscaper and HVAC technician, using these identities to gain access to victims in Squirrel Hill.
On a Facebook account seeming to belong to Mr. Clinton, a post from November 2021 advertises the flyer of a contracting company called Elite General Contracting.
“Recommend,” the account’s owner commented above the flyer, which claims the business has been serving Pittsburgh since 1982.
No company with that name could be found in Pennsylvania’s public record of business entities, or in an online search.
After calling the number on the flyer, the call was redirected to a voicemail message that said, “Hi, this is Andrew.”
The Pittsburgh Jewish Chronicle this month reported that Mr. Clinton posted on Facebook through a fake account to recommend the contracting company’s services.
“Would be malpractice to brag and not mention Andi. Amazing generous young man!” wrote Paul Wolfe, the fake owner of the account, alongside Elite’s phone number and before and after photos of a kitchen project.
The “Paul Wolfe” account was one of a number of online personas Mr. Clinton used to infiltrate community and religious Facebook groups, Detective Rosato said.
The vast majority of the hundreds of items recovered by police so far appear to have little, if any, significant monetary value, with one of the pieces Mr. Clinton had most prominently displayed in his room being a diploma belonging to a local rabbi. While he is alleged to have cashed checks given to him for home improvement work that he never even started, he doesn’t appear to have sold any of the memorabilia.
During this time, Mr. Clinton was mostly living at his parents’ home in Squirrel Hill. Detective Rosato said Mr. Clinton’s mother and stepfather are cooperating with the investigation.
Detective Rosato said Mr. Clinton was so dedicated that it was almost as if it was a full-time job. He also stressed that there may be more victims than previously thought as the investigation continues.
“All these different crimes, sooner or later they were going to catch up, but he just kept [doing it] continuously,” he said. “It wasn’t just one day. It was every day.”
Staff writer Jesse Bunch contributed.
Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter: @MickStinelli





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.