In a relatively rare move, federal prosecutors are dropping a drug case against a Homewood man after a federal judge made a field trip to his house, the scene of a Pittsburgh police raid, and ruled to suppress evidence because he said the officers should have known the building was a multi-unit apartment and not a single-family home.
Prosecutors on Friday asked U.S. District Judge David Cercone to dismiss an indictment against Lynn Hargraves, 69, of Idlewild Street.
Mr. Hargraves had been indicted in 2019 on a count of possession with intent to deliver fentanyl, heroin and crack.
City police searched the house in the 7200 block of Idlewild on May 15, 2019, after an informant said Mr. Hargraves was dealing drugs out of the residence.
He and his lawyer, Charles Hoebler, filed a suppression motion to toss the warrant as not specific enough, saying the cops raided the entire house and bashed in doors without realizing that various people lived there besides Mr. Hargraves, as should have been evident by the multiple mailboxes and electrical meters on the outside and various locked doors on the inside.
Judge Cercone held a suppression hearing last August and then visited the house in December. He agreed with the defense and tossed the evidence from the search.
The government appealed to the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals but then decided to drop the indictment.
The case represents a rare loss on a suppression issue in federal court, where the conviction rate stands at about 95%.
Mr. Hoebler declined comment. The U.S. attorney's office does not comment on pending cases.
In a February opinion, Judge Cercone said the police should have known they were searching a multi-unit apartment. Hargraves lived on the third floor while others lived on the other floors, but a police search warrant indicated the house was a single-family residence.
"Each officer testifying at the hearing on August 3, 2021, unwaveringly denied having any reason to believe from the facts and circumstances confronting them that the residence was a multi-unit dwelling or set up as a multi-resident home," the judge said. "These denials were persistent and almost uniform in explanation, notwithstanding that, as the government was forced to concede, 'there [were] three mailboxes you can see clearly [affixed right next to the front door].'"
The case began when police said an informant told them he'd bought drugs from Mr. Hargraves and that he lived on the third floor of the house and drove a green Jeep. The informant didn't say if anyone else lived there. Police set up surveillance and said they saw people coming and going who looked like addicts. They stopped one of them and found drugs on him. A detective then wrote up a warrant to search the building, which Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge David Cashman signed.
Mr. Hargraves left the building and when he came back, officers stopped him. He yelled to a group of people nearby to "go get Ray" and tell Ray to "go to my house," police said. Someone in the crowd said OK and began running.
Police then asked for all available units to help secure the house for the search. A sergeant noticed three electrical meters on the property and asked a lieutenant if the residence was an apartment building and not a house. According to testimony at the hearing, the lieutenant "brushed off" the sergeant and didn't answer. The lieutenant, before reviewing the search warrant, then gave the command to knock and announce a forced entry. Officers smashed in the front door with a battering ram.
After encountering locked interior doors, they used the ram to smash them open and clear the floors of threats as they proceeded to Mr. Hargraves' room on the third floor.
After the sweep, the lieutenant told the other officers that the mailboxes next to the front door might indicate multiple units. After that, the police limited their search to the third floor.
Judge Cercone noted that all of the officers questioned at the hearing said they didn't notice the mailboxes or other evidence that the house was an apartment building before the sweep.
The defense argued that this lack of awareness undermined the credibility of the police and that the warrant was invalid because it wasn't specific enough to what should be searched.
Judge Cercone decided to go to the house himself with the lawyers for both sides and discovered that the mailboxes made it clear that the house was divided into apartments.
The government argued that the warrant was valid because it provided information known to police at the time.
Judge Cercone said that police obtained a warrant to search the whole house, believing that Mr. Hargraves controlled the entire structure. But at the suppression hearing, he said, the officers indicated there was not probable cause to search the whole house because they saw clear evidence of multiple apartments.
The judge said the search warrant affidavit prepared by police should have focused on Mr. Hargraves' third-floor apartment only, because the informant had said Mr. Hargraves lives in that unit.
"From the beginning, the [informant] had relayed that defendant was living on the third floor and selling drugs out of the residence," the judge said.
Mr. Hargraves' driver's license also indicated he lived in Apartment No. 3, the judge said, and surveillance showed people coming and going "in a manner completely independent" of Mr. Hargraves.
"These known facts would have caused a reasonable officer to question whether there were multiple units within the structure," he said, "and a simple examination of the front façade of the residence pursuant to such an inquiry would have revealed the presence of the three mailboxes with designations on them for separate apartments as well as a number of garbage cans that were suggestive of a multi-unit dwelling."
The judge did not find fault with Judge Cashman but instead with the police.
"The information in the affidavit as to the single resident character of the house was inaccurate and misleading," he said. "Critical information bearing on the multi-unit character of the residence and defendant's occupancy of only the third apartment was not submitted for Judge Cashman's consideration."



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.