The estate of the late David Munchinski, who spent nearly 26 years in prison for a crime he didn't commit, has settled a federal wrongful conviction suit he brought nearly a decade ago for $8.75 million.

Mr. Munchinski, who died in February, had sued Fayette County prosecutors and the state police in 2013 over his conviction in the 1977 killings of Peter Alford and Raymond Gierke.

He had won his freedom 11 years ago when a federal judge voided his 1986 conviction on grounds that the prosecutors hid evidence that could have exonerated him, including contradictory statements from a now-dead witness.

He filed his suit two years later and had been living in Florida as the case wound through federal court. He died in late February after giving a deposition. He was 69 and had long suffered from Parkinson's disease.

Advertise with us

The parties settled last week.

Federal court records do not reveal settlement amounts when civil cases are resolved, but Mr. Munchinski’s long-time lawyer, Noah Geary, said the figure was $8.75 million.

Lawyers representing the Fayette County District Attorney's Office and the state police did not respond to requests for comment or terms of the settlement.

Mr. Munchinski had said all along that he was innocent. But he didn't get out of prison until U.S. Magistrate Judge Lisa Pupo Lenihan ruled in 2011 that the conviction was improper.

In releasing him immediately pending an appeal by the state, she said the continued incarceration of Munchinski, then 60, would cause him "irreparable harm."

Advertise with us

"I think it's good," was Mr. Munchinski’s only comment at the time as he shuffled down a hallway, still in shackles.

He had been convicted in 1986, along with Leon Scaglione, of killing the two men at Bear Rocks, Fayette County. Scaglione died in prison 10 years later.

No physical evidence had linked Mr. Munchinski to the murders. The case against him was built mostly on the testimony of one witness, Richard Bowen, a burglar and forger. He had said he had witnessed the rape and murder of the two men, but he also changed his story repeatedly.

Mr. Munchinski's lawyers said prosecutors and state troopers had withheld exculpatory evidence in his trial and in various proceedings after the conviction.

After Judge Lenihan's decision, the state appealed to the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals but lost.

Advertise with us

The appellate judges described the state's violations of exculpatory evidence rules as "staggering" and said that Mr. Munchinski had demonstrated his innocence "by clear and convincing evidence."

The circuit judges also called into question why the state was appealing at all, saying it was hard to understand why prosecutors were defending a "badly tainted and highly suspect conviction."

In 2013, Mr. Munchinski filed suit against prosecutors Gerald Solomon and Ralph Warman, both of whom had become Fayette County judges and are now retired, along with the estate of a late state police sergeant, George Fayock, who had overseen the investigation.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com