A violent criminal who represented himself and took advantage of a U.S. Supreme Court decision to get out of federal prison early is headed back to the lockup because he walked away from the halfway house where he was supposed to finish his sentence.

Lamont Laprade will have to do another eight months in a federal penitentiary.

U.S. District Judge Mark Hornak on Tuesday imposed that term after Laprade pleaded guilty to a charge of escaping from Renewal, a Pittsburgh step-down unit for prisoners.

Laprade, 43, of Huntington, W.Va., had opened fire on a bank customer in a Hempfield parking lot during the robbery of a credit union in 2010 in which his partner, David Mathis, shot a teller in the chest and pistol-whipped another teller.

Advertise with us

Laprade was the getaway driver, but when a bank customer pulled into the parking lot, he leaned out the window and fired a shot at him with a .45.

He represented himself at his federal trial, but it didn't go well for him.

He was quickly convicted of bank robbery, armed bank robbery, conspiracy and carrying a gun during a crime of violence.

U.S. District Judge Donetta Ambrose, now retired, gave him 15 years and eight months.

While in prison, he appealed his sentence for the gun crime based on a 2013 Supreme Court decision out of Virginia in which the court said any facts that increase a mandatory minimum sentence must be submitted to a jury and not decided by a judge.

Advertise with us

In Alleyne v. United States, the justices said that if someone is convicted of using or carrying a gun during a violent crime but sentenced for "brandishing" a gun, the defendant's Sixth Amendment right to be tried by a jury has been violated. The high court said carrying a gun, brandishing a gun and firing a gun are all separate offenses that a jury must decide.

In Laprade's case, an appellate court ruled in 2016 that Judge Ambrose told the jury that the government didn't have to prove Laprade fired or displayed his gun, but she still sentenced him for firing it. That crime carries a mandatory 10-year term but the sentence should have been five years.

At a re-sentencing in 2017, Judge Ambrose knocked his sentence down by the five years over the objections of one of the victim tellers, who argued through tears that Laprade should be held as accountable for the violence as Mathis, who got 25 years.

Laprade served his time and was sent to Renewal. But he didn't stay there and a grand jury indicted him in October 2019. Federal authorities arrested him in December of that year.

Laprade tried to represent himself again and once again it didn't go so well.

Advertise with us

At a 2019 hearing to make sure he knew what he was doing in not using a lawyer, he clearly didn't understand the role of a grand jury, instead insisting that his escape case was a civil matter governed by "contract law" while also repeatedly interrupting and insulting the judge as being a "quasi prosecutor."

"I hope you don't take this personally," Judge Hornak told him in that hearing. "I'm really speaking as a legal matter, based on my time as a lawyer and as a judge. It's all complete nonsense. All the civil stuff you have in there — please let me finish, sir. It has nothing to do with the criminal charges against you. Nothing. Zero. It's senseless."

The case dragged on for several years, delayed in part by COVID, but the judge eventually scheduled a competency and plea hearing and imposed the eight-month sentence.