A federal judge on Monday ordered that a Pittsburgh tattoo artist accused of molesting a child in Haiti for three years be detained, mostly because she said he's at risk to kill himself.

U.S. Magistrate Judge Patricia Dodge said Corrigan Clay, 43, of West Oakland, will remain locked up pending trial.

Federal agents arrested him last week after a grand jury handed up an indictment on a count of engaging in illicit sexual conduct in a foreign place.

Mr. Clay, who had lived in Haiti from 2008 before moving to Pittsburgh with a new wife in 2020, is accused of sexually abusing a minor in Haiti from January 2014 until December 2017.

Advertise with us

The Post-Gazette does not identify the victims of sex crimes.

The allegations against him originated in Florida with local authorities. The case was later adopted by the Justice Department after an investigation by the U.S. Department of Homeland Security.

Alicia Bove, a Justice Department lawyer, said Mr. Clay molested the girl "undetected for years" and asked that he be detained as a danger to children, a risk to flee and a suicide concern.

In arguing for detention, she recounted the details of the alleged molestation, saying he had confessed to sheriff's deputies in Florida and to his mother in an email. She said he has ties to Haiti, Germany and Canada and owns a 41-foot boat on the Florida coast within an hour of international waters, meaning he has access to take off. A federal agent also testified that until his arrest by agents last week, Mr. Clay had no idea his case would be in federal court and thought it was a local matter.

"We have great concerns about him not showing up and fleeing," Ms. Bove said.

Advertise with us

She also said he has asked his family to pray for him because he might commit suicide.

Mr. Clay had previously lived in Haiti with his ex-wife, Shelley Jean Clay, and their four children, two of them biological and two of them adopted. The pair had founded The Apparent Project, a nonprofit ministry and artisan's group originally set up to create art out of trash in Haiti with the intent of stimulating the Haitian economy and helping poor children. Corrigan Clay worked as a tattoo artist in Haiti and had his own shop. He had apparently also worked as a pastor at one point.

Shelley Clay now lives in Florida with the children. Mr. Clay had met his current wife, Ruth Portnoff, in Haiti where she had worked as an agriculturalist from 2015 to 2020. The two married in 2018 and now live in Oakland with their 1-year-old.

William Difenderfer, Mr. Clay's lawyer, said his client is not a risk to flee and argued that his wife and her parents, who live a few doors away, can watch over him and protect the 1-year-old. Ms. Portnoff said her husband immediately sought out counseling after the allegations surfaced and the two go to counseling sessions together.

"He was candid about what happened," she said. "I asked a lot of questions."

Advertise with us

Her mother, Lynn Portnoff, said she and her husband would be willing to take Mr. Clay in and keep an eye on him.

Mr. Difenderfer said his client drove to Florida to talk to law officers there about the allegations and could have fled then, but he didn't.

"He's confronting this head-on," he said.

As an added assurance, he and Ms. Portnoff said they would sell the Florida boat.

Judge Dodge said, however, that detention is warranted.

Advertise with us

The burden of proof in federal detention hearings is on the defendant to show why he shouldn't be locked up, not on the government to show why he should be. It's the opposite of the state court system. In this case, Judge Dodge had concerns about Mr. Clay’s ties to other nations and the fact that he would be living in a home with a small child.

But she said it was his emotional state that most troubled her.

"I'm emphasizing the risk of suicide," she said.