A doctor who gave out pain pills to a woman in exchange for sex, including at least one act in his office that she recorded on her wristwatch camera, is headed to federal prison for a year and a half.

Emilio Ramon Navarro, 60, had pleaded guilty in October to illegally prescribing oxycodone and healthcare fraud. He had been indicted in 2020 on 161 counts.

U.S. District Judge J. Nicholas Ranjan on Tuesday gave him 18 months behind bars and three years of probation over the objections of his lawyer, who asked for a non-custodial sentence.

Navarro had practiced in Perryopolis in Fayette County and Mount Pleasant in Westmoreland County.

Advertise with us

In 2018 and 2019, he prescribed oxycodone and oxymorphone numerous times to a woman identified only as A.W. in exchange for sex. A superseding indictment added more counts involving a second woman.

At his plea, Navarro admitted that in 2018 he wrote A.W. nine prescriptions for 300 doses of oxycodone and 240 doses of oxymorphone for no medical purpose.

Medicaid and Medicare paid for the prescriptions, which is the basis for the healthcare fraud counts.

Navarro and his lawyer, Patrick Thomassey, argued for probation instead of prison, saying he suffers from various medical problems, can't practice medicine anymore and is unlikely to repeat his behavior. Mr. Thomassey presented numerous letters written on Navarro's behalf from patients extolling his virtues.

But prosecutors Bob Cessar and Mark Gurzo asked for prison on the grounds that Navarro was a "drug dealer who dealt drugs in exchange for sex."

Advertise with us

They said he prescribed drugs to one woman, identified as Victim 1, for his own sexual gratification and was "instrumental" in her becoming an addict.

In 2009, they said, he initially prescribed Percocet to Victim 1 for pain she suffered in a violent mugging. He later prescribed a combination of oxycodone and oxymorphone.

She became addicted and asked for his help to wean off the drugs.

In April 2018, she came to his office for an appointment. He began hugging and kissing her and tried to pull her pants down, the prosecutors said. She resisted and he put his hand down her pants and had her place her hand down his, she said. After the encounter, he wrote her a prescription for the pain pills.

Mr. Cessar and Mr. Gurza said the woman, worried that no one would believe he had sexually abused her, bought a wristwatch camera to record her next visit on April 30, 2018. She also brought her children in the hopes that it would "dissaude" Navarro from making sexual advances.

Advertise with us

It didn't.

The prosecutors said that she went into the exam room with her kids and Navarro and turned on her camera. He ushered her into his office, leaving the kids in the exam room, and locked the door. He then forced her to perform oral sex, prosecutors said, which she recorded on the watch camera.

After that, he wrote her scripts for the drugs.

At later appointments, a similar scenario played out, with Navarro prescribing the drugs "for no legitimate medical purpose but in return for sexual favors."

He then ripped off Medicaid and Medicare by causing them to pay for the woman's scripts.

Advertise with us

In addition to the prison term, Judge Ranjan ordered Navarro to pay a $5,000 fine.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com