A federal prison inmate acquitted in the massacre of six people in Wilkinsburg in 2016 has sued the police and Allegheny County on grounds of malicious prosecution, as did his co-defendant the week before.

Cheron Shelton, 35, filed a complaint Friday in U.S. District Court that largely mirrors one filed by Robert Thomas, whose case was dismissed by a judge.

Allegheny County police said the pair attacked a cookout crowd on March 9, 2016, with Mr. Thomas firing a pistol from the front of a house to herd people to the back porch, where police said Shelton shot them with an assault rifle.

A jury found Shelton not guilty in 2020. Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Edward Borkowski threw out the case against Mr. Thomas before opening statements were to begin when the prosecution said it would not be calling jailhouse witnesses. In the judge's view, prosecutors didn't have enough evidence without those witnesses to prove his guilt.

Advertise with us

Shelton said in his suit that he had nothing to do with the shooting and doesn't know who did it.

"Defendants brought their charges against the Plaintiff Cheron Shelton based solely on unsupported and unsubstantiated statements from unreliable confidential jailhouse informants, and questionable circumstantial evidence which did not connect Cheron Shelton to the crimes for which he was accused," the suit says.

Shelton spent four years in jail waiting for the trial and had faced the death penalty if he had been convicted.

The suit raises claims of malicious prosecution, violation of due process and similar counts.

Shelton is serving an eight-year federal prison sentence at FCI Hazelton in West Virginia.

Advertise with us

Last April, U.S. District Judge Arthur Schwab imposed that term, which was agreed to by his lawyer and federal prosecutors as part of a plea deal involving an illegal weapon.

A federal grand jury indicted him in 2020 in connection with a rifle found at his mother's house in Homewood during the investigation of the Wilkinsburg killings.

Shelton can't have guns or ammunition because he has a prior drug conviction.

The .22-caliber rifle, reported stolen out of Uniontown, was not the same one used in the massacre. That gun was an AK-47 assault rifle.