The Allegheny County District Attorney’s Office on Wednesday filed an appeal opposing a Common Pleas Court judge’s decision to give a man convicted of murder a new trial.

The DA’s office argued in its filing that Judge Anthony M. Mariani made an error in his decision to give the defendant, Charles Becher, a new trial on the basis that it was “in the interest of justice.”

Mr. Becher, 25, was found guilty in October of third-degree murder in connection to a fatal 2020 shooting outside the Club Erotica strip club in McKees Rocks.

Judge Mariani said he was throwing out the jury’s verdict because they may have been influenced by a prosecution witness’ testimony that one of Mr. Becher’s cousins said the defendant was going to “‘smoke all of them” on the night of the shooting. The judge said that statement was improper hearsay.

Advertise with us

But Judge Mariani is quoted in the DA’s filing as telling the jury that they shouldn’t take that statement as proof, nor should they take it as an indication of the defendant’s state of mind since he was not present when it was spoken.

That statement “made outside the presence of the defendant cannot be proof of the defendant's intent or state of mind unless you determine from the evidence that the defendant was conscious of and promoted the statement, or endorsed that statement in some fashion,” he told the jury.

There is no reason to believe the jury did not listen to those instructions, the DA’s office argues.

Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter: @MickStinelli