An Allegheny County jury found a man not guilty of a double murder stemming from a shooting last year outside of a McKees Rocks strip club.
Jurors on Tuesday acquitted Khalil Walls of all charges related to the Jan. 29, 2021, shooting outside Club Erotica on Island Avenue. Charges against Mr. Walls, 27, included first- and third-degree murder, voluntary manslaughter and involuntary manslaughter.
Mr. Walls and 25-year-old Charles Becher were both charged with homicide in the aftermath of the shooting that killed Christopher Butler, 22, and Seth McDermitt, 31. The shooting had stemmed from a fight involving two groups of friends outside the strip club.
The jury deliberated for several days.
Becher was found guilty in October of third-degree murder.
Common Pleas Judge Anthony Mariani, however, threw out that verdict and ordered a new trial. Judge Mariani at the time said the jury might have been influenced by what he called an improper hearsay statement from a witness for the prosecution.
Read More
One of Becher’s cousins testified that Becher was going to “smoke all of them” on the night of the shooting. Judge Mariani said a new trial is “in the interest of justice.”
The District Attorney’s Office has appealed Judge Mariani’s decision to the state Superior Court.
The appeal contends that Judge Mariani told the jury they shouldn’t take the statement in question as proof, nor should they take it as an indication of the defendant’s state of mind since he wasn’t present when it was said.
That statement “made outside the presence of the defendant cannot be proof of the defendant’s intent or state of mind unless you determine from the evidence that the defendant was conscious of and promoted the statement or endorsed that statement in some fashion,” Judge Mariani had told the jury.
The DA’s office has argued there is no reason to believe the jury didn’t heed those instructions. The decision remains on appeal.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.