A group of Churchill residents this week filed an appeal in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court to halt the construction of an Amazon distribution center in the borough.

The filing, which names 18 members of a group called Churchill Future, which lobbied against the project, challenges the borough council’s Dec. 21 approval of a conditional land use permit. The 5-2 vote cleared the way for construction to begin on the facility at the former Westinghouse Research and Technology Park.

Gavin Robb, the borough’s solicitor, said he received a copy of the filing Friday morning and was in the process of reviewing it. He declined to comment further, citing the pending litigation.

The appeal claims three borough council members — Council President Jay Dorwin, councilmembers Matt Castiglia and Diane Law — who voted in favor of the construction had bias and should have recused themselves from the process.

Advertise with us

After these three legislators expressed their approval for the development prior to the vote, the appeal states, Churchill Future asked them to recuse themselves because they “had already made up their minds prior to the process even beginning.”

“Had these 3 predisposed council members recused themselves from voting as required, the vote to approve would have been a 2-2 vote, rather than a 5-2 vote, and would have resulted in a denial of the conditional use application,” the appeal reads.

The appeal goes on to say that the council’s approval of the permit was “arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, and contrary to the law.”

Amazon, as the applicant, failed to show evidence at the borough’s public meetings that it would follow the community’s noise ordinances, even as Churchill Future’s experts testified that the facility would make enough noise to have a detrimental impact on neighbors, the appeal states.

The appeal continues to claim that Amazon failed to properly address ordinances regarding air, lighting, traffic, parking and zoning. The group also says the development would be inconsistent with the borough’s character.

Advertise with us

“In sum, the Distribution Center is wholly inconsistent with past development of the Borough and its current character,” the appeal concludes.

The plans for the facility, included in the appeal, detail a 4½-story building sitting at approximately 2.6 million square feet that is expected to employ between 1,000 and 1,500 people.

Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter: @MickStinelli