Judge Wrenna Watson not only is one of the new judges on Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, but also she is the latest in a judicial family.
Judge Watson, who was sworn in Thursday, was preceded on the bench by her father, 98-year-old J. Warren Watson. He was elected in 1965 and was among the first Black judges in the county. One of her brothers, Robert C. Watson, was appointed as a judge for a stint.
After she was elected in November, her father dug out his old law books in case his daughter needed advice, she said.
“I am here to try to make a difference,” Judge Watson, 67, said after she took her oath of office. The Hill District native previously was a private attorney and mental health hearing officer.
While some candidates focused on judicial reform and rethinking criminal justice, Judge Watson said she ran her campaign based on fairness.
“I’m fair,” she said. “I listen to people.”
Some changes in the criminal justice system that people have been clamoring for recently don’t pertain to judicial decisions, she said, but every judge has the opportunity to make a difference when they take their seats on the bench.

“What every one of us can do, and needs to do, to start change happens every day — the first day you sit on the bench with every case in front of you — and that’s to be fair, to listen to people and treat them with respect,” she said. “And that’s what I plan on doing.”
“There is not a person that [knows] Wrenna Watson that will not say, ‘This a woman who not only has integrity, who not only is impartial, who not only listens but treats everyone fairly and with respect,’ ” said attorney Phil DiLucente, who spoke at her swearing-in.
Mel Blount, the former Steelers cornerback, also spoke at the ceremony, saying Ms. Watson’s election was a win for the whole county.
“We need more strong African American women like you, and so we hope that you can continue to be a great leader and set good examples for all of us,” he said.
Judge Watson was one of three Black women elected to the bench in November. She will serve in the court’s criminal division. The other two are Nicola Henry-Taylor, a private attorney and director of diversity and inclusion at the Duquesne University School of Law, and Tiffany Sizemore, an associate professor at Duquesne’s law school. They will serve in the family division.
Prominent among this year’s new judges were candidates promising to take a fresh approach to justice. Judge Lisa Middleman, a public defender and former candidate for district attorney, was one of them.

After her election, she said she and others had “a vision for a reform of the system,” including more accessibility and accountability for judges. She will be in family court.
Also entering family court are Jessel Costa, a private attorney; Sabrina Korbel, legal director of the Women’s Center & Shelter of Greater Pittsburgh; and Chelsa Wagner, the former Allegheny County controller.
The family division focuses on such matters as child custody, divorce, adoption and protection-from-abuse orders.
Tom Caulfield, previously a district justice, is the only new judge other than Judge Watson to be placed on criminal court. Judges Bruce Beemer and Elliot Howsie, previously appointed to fill vacancies on the bench, were officially elected in November and will continue to serve in the criminal division.
Before President Judge Kim Berkeley Clark administered the oath, she noted that her parents brought her to the swearing-in of Judge Warren Watson in 1965.
“That’s a long time ago, but I still remember it because it was so important,” she said.

She mentioned a photo in the Carnegie Museum of Art’s Teenie Harris Archive, the vast collection of images taken by the iconic Black photographer Charles “Teenie” Harris, that shows Judge Watson and her siblings posed in her father’s office shortly after he took his oath.
In the picture, she and her siblings stand behind her father, who is dressed in his black robe. Decades later, he and Judge Watson’s daughter, Michelle Watson, stood with her on Thursday as she put on her own.
Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter: @MickStinelli






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.