A little over a month has passed since the death of Jim Rogers, an unarmed Black man who died in the hospital after Pittsburgh police used a stun gun on him during an arrest in Bloomfield.
Despite three public rallies and a prod from the district attorney, little information about the investigation has been released by county investigators — including the identity of the officers involved and the official cause of Mr. Rogers’ death.
When asked for updates about the investigation, Chris Kearns, Allegheny County police superintendent, said via email, “We do not release the names of involved officers in critical incident investigations. The release of officers names is up to the involved agency.”
Asked separately, Cara Cruz, a public information officer for Pittsburgh Public Safety, said, “There are no plans to release any names at this time. Public Safety is allowing the County to complete its investigation as our own internal review takes place simultaneously.”
Reports from the family of Mr. Rogers and video captured during part of the Oct. 13 arrest show an officer using a Taser on the 54-year-old while detaining him on Harriet Street.
Police were called about Mr. Rogers riding a bike that was for sale on a resident’s lawn and smoking a cigarette on a home’s porch.
Read More
In a notification from the Allegheny County Medical Examiner sent via email on Oct. 15, Mr. Rogers’ death was listed as “hospital patient died.” No cause of death was given.
According to Dr. Cyril Wecht, a Pittsburgh-based forensic pathologist and former Allegheny County coroner, the autopsy and toxicology report for a death similar to Mr. Rogers’ wouldn’t take more than two weeks.
“What they’re waiting for are police reports, investigative reports,” Dr. Wecht said of his experience with cases similar to that of Mr. Rogers. “Those are valid, but again, that doesn’t take months.”
Dr. Wecht was coroner from 1970 to 1980 and again from 1996 to 2006. He’s provided analysis on high-profile forensic cases like the assassinations of President John F. Kennedy and Sen. Robert F. Kennedy, among others.
According to Dr. Wecht, what would have taken place by now is a thorough autopsy and toxicology screen to determine whether use of force by officers played a role in the death.
Apart from standard autopsy procedures, Dr. Wecht said the medical examiner likely would examine muscle tissue in the arms, back and thighs of the deceased for signs of hemorrhage that may have occurred from applied pressure during the arrest.
In Mr. Rogers’ case, a medical examiner would also be looking for Taser marks, Dr. Wecht said.
“Most often, you don’t find them because people are wearing clothing,” he explained. “When you look to see if there are markings, then you want to get the police report, what did they say, how many Taser shots were fired.”
Dr. Wecht said Taser manufacturers include guidelines that recommend officers avoid targeting a person’s vital centers, where shock can affect cardiac rhythm — especially when used excessively.
The deceased’s medical history will further help determine the cause of death, records Dr. Wecht said are collected during the autopsy process.
Here, the examiner is looking for history of issues like heart disease, high blood pressure, pulmonary insufficiency and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease that may have played a role in the death.
“In a case involving a police-related death, it behooves the medical examiner or forensic pathologist to be much more thorough and probing, to make sure you get the records,” Dr. Wecht said, though he mentioned that these records are often superficial or may not be available.
“You want to try to speak with doctors if medical attention was given, if possible.” he added. “In cases that are controversial, speak with the attending physician and hear from him exactly what he did. That’s very important.”
That means the Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s office would have to speak with staff at UPMC Mercy hospital in the city’s Uptown neighborhood, where Mr. Rogers was taken in a police vehicle after the incident. There, he was pronounced dead at 10:15 a.m. on Oct. 14.
Following the autopsy, Dr. Wecht said a toxicology screen determines whether drugs were present in the deceased’s system. While drugs may show up, he mentioned that based on when they were taken and when the death occurred, they may not be relevant to the investigation.
Following the work of the medical examiner, any developments in Mr. Rogers’ case are reliant on city and county police investigations — and it’s not just the public waiting for answers.
In a statement released on Nov. 12, Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen Zappala said, “It is both frustrating and unacceptable that this investigation has dragged on this long. I will not permit this type of delay in the future.”
During Dr. Wecht’s two periods as county coroner, the position held the power to subpoena and could conduct an inquest — an investigation into the circumstances of the death conducted by the coroner.
While a 1995 ballot initiative dissolved the Allegheny County coroner’s office and replaced it with the current medical examiner system, Dr. Wecht said the power of inquest was retained.
But since then, an inquest has not been used.
“That’s regrettable,” Dr. Wecht said, “because that is a way to bring out facts which may never see the light of day.”



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.