Isaac Smith — whom police arrested Friday in connection to the September killing of Karli Short, a pregnant McKeesport woman — shot Ms. Smith in the head and had planned her killing, police say in an affidavit.
After an investigation, police determined that Mr. Smith, 25, of McKeesport, was responsible for Ms. Short’s death. Police said Ms. Short, 26, was shot in the head a little before 12:30 a.m. on Sept. 13 in the backyard of the home she shared with her uncle.
Ms. Short was five months pregnant at the time with Mr. Smith’s child, police said.
Mr. Smith was denied bail at an arraignment Saturday and was taken to the Allegheny County Jail. He is charged with criminal homicide and homicide of an unborn child, court records show.
According to a criminal complaint, Ms. Short’s family said they knew Mr. Smith only by his first name, Isaac, and that he may have worked at PNC Bank in McKeesport. No one in Ms. Short’s family had met Mr. Smith.
A detective from the McKeesport Police Department later identified Mr. Smith by previously recognizing him from PNC Bank.
Read More
County police obtained search warrants for cell phone records and forensic downloads as part of their investigation.
In the affidavit, police said they found no information on Mr. Smith’s phone that he told anyone about Ms. Short’s pregnancy. During the investigation, police found that Ms. Short sent him text messages on Sept. 11 asking him for money and discussing plans for a gender reveal party.
Police said in the complaint that Mr. Smith left a witness’s home at 11 p.m. on Sept. 12, to “see a friend’s new puppy in Homestead.” The witness said Mr. Smith sent the witness a text message at midnight.
Both Ms. Short and her uncle, Percy Reese, lived at the home on 25th Street in McKeesport. In the affidavit, Mr. Reese told detectives that he heard Ms. Short talking on her phone Sept. 13, asking, “Are you coming to the front or the back?,” and walking to the back of the house. That’s when Mr. Reese said he heard a gunshot.
Police said Mr. Smith called Ms. Short at 12:20 a.m. using a TracFone that someone else had gotten him. Police determined that the call was made near Ms. Short’s home and lasted a little over a minute.
Mr. Reese began to call out for Ms. Short but was not able to walk to the backyard because he told police that he is disabled. He told police that gunshots are not uncommon in his neighborhood and that he assumed Ms. Short went with whomever she was meeting in the back alley.
McKeesport police’s ShotSpotter system recorded a gunshot in the area of 25th Street at 12:23 a.m. on Sept. 13, the complaint said. Video from the alarm system shows that Ms. Short walked out the back door at 12:22 a.m., but does “not clearly show the part of the backyard where Ms. Short’s body was found,” the affidavit said.
On the evening of Sept. 13, Allegheny County detectives interviewed Mr. Smith and that he admitted to having a sexual relationship with Ms. Short and that she told him she was pregnant with his child, the complaint said.
Ms. Short was the daughter of Brandon Short, a former National Football League linebacker and current member of Penn State University board of trustees. On Friday night, Mr. Short posted on his Twitter account a thank-you for the prayers and support “during this difficult time.”
Thank you for all your prayers and support during this difficult time. Through the outstanding work from both the @AlleghenyCoPD and @McKeesport_PD there has been an arrest in the murder of my beloved daughter, Karli, and her unborn child. Thank you ???????? #justiceforkarli pic.twitter.com/wtCXGYIu0M
— Brandon Short (@brandonshort43) November 6, 2021
Ms. Short’s family had offered a $20,000 reward for anyone who had information that could lead to an arrest.
Mr. Smith has a preliminary hearing scheduled for Nov. 24.
Kellen Stepler: kstepler@post-gazette.com


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.