A former Clairton woman dismembered her dead husband's body, threw the parts in the trash and then collected his Social Security benefits for more than four years until federal agents in Nevada, where she had moved in 2017, figured out he was long dead, according to a federal complaint.
Nancy Kay Shedleski, 69, was charged in Las Vegas last week with theft of government money — about $121,000 in benefits she was not entitled to receive — following an investigation by the Social Security Administration’s Office of Inspector General with help from Allegheny County police.
When confronted by agents last year she initially said her husband Joseph Shedleski was doing what she called a "walk-about," traveling around the country.
She later admitted that he'd died in 2015 in the basement of their Clairton home and she didn't tell anyone.
Social Security's Office of Inspector General investigates benefit fraud cases across the country, and it's not uncommon for someone to be charged with continuing to collect after a spouse dies.
But this case is more elaborate than most. Agents say Ms. Shedleski dismembered her husband's body and put it in the trash after he died on Aug. 28, 2015, then pretended he was still alive for two years while she was living alone in Clairton and for another 27 months after she moved to Las Vegas in 2017.
Federal prosecutors in Las Vegas said Shedleski illegally collected benefits from August 2015 to December 2019.
An anonymous tip unraveled her scheme.
According to an affidavit by Social Security Agent Michael Stuto, in June 2019 the Social Security Administration received a tip that Joseph Shedleski had disappeared in 2015 and Nancy was using his benefits.
Records showed Joseph was getting about $2,000 a month since 2009 and deposited it into a joint account with his wife at Key Bank. Agent Stuto then examined Joseph's Medicare records. He found that Joseph had last received care at Jefferson Regional Medical Center in May 2015.
The agent said in his affidavit that he found it unusual that a man in his 70s hadn't received any additional care for more than four years.
Social Security records showed that Nancy and Joseph's addresses had been updated to an apartment in Las Vegas in September 2017.
In July 2019, the Las Vegas Social Security office called Joseph's number but got no answer. Employees tried Nancy, got no answer and left a message. Two days later she called back and said she and Joseph lived together at the apartment.
In December of that year, agents paid her a visit. She initially said he was traveling and she hadn't seen him since October, Agent Stuto said.
Then she said he had disappeared in August 2015. Then, according to the affidavit, she said he had died on Aug. 28, 2015.
A couple of months later agents interviewed her again.
This time, according to the affidavit, she "admitted to dismembering J.P.S's body, packaging the body parts and throwing them out in the trash." She said she told her family that Joseph had died.
"Shedleski confirmed there was no ambulance, no funeral, no burial and no cremation for J.P.S.," Agent Stuto said.
He said Nancy admitted to using his benefits for her living expenses and that she had submitted a change of address form for Joseph when she moved to Nevada in 2017.
Records showed that she regularly transferred the Social Security money out of the joint Key Bank account and into her own Chase Bank account.
Ms. Shedleski appeared in federal court on Monday and a U.S. magistrate judge released her on bond pending trial.
Typically after a complaint is filed in federal court, prosecutors have 30 days to bring a grand jury indictment.
Ms. Shedleski's public defender did not respond to a request for comment.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.