The man convicted of first-degree murder for shooting another man inside a South Side bar in 2017 was sentenced to mandatory life in prison with no chance of parole.

Kolbrin Holyfield, 27, was convicted in July of first-degree murder in the killing of Dahrique Smith, 25, inside Rowdy Buck — since renamed Trixie’s Game Room and Bar — on East Carson Street in May 2017.

On Tuesday, Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Beth Lazzara handed down the sentence.

During the criminal investigation, Pittsburgh police said Holyfield entered the bar with three people. He then exited the bar briefly before re-entering and walking off camera. From video footage, Mr. Smith can be seen walking over in the same direction a little time later where the shooter reappears on camera holding a firearm and then shooting Mr. Smith.

Advertise with us

Surveillance video from Rowdy Buck

Smith then runs out the door that connected Rowdy Buck to another business and outside, where he collapsed. Holyfield can be seen chasing after him.

Two unnamed witnesses spoke with police, according to the affidavit. They said they arrived at the Rowdy Buck bar with Holyfield and were able to provide a fuller picture.

The first witness said that they had been at the Drip Lounge on Warrington Avenue the evening of May 20, 2017, with the second witness. Eventually, Holyfield, who had been in school with the first witness since eighth grade, joined them.

The three of them then left to go to Rowdy Buck. When they got to the area, the second witness said that they dropped Holyfield off before parking and went to wait in line outside the bar. There, they saw another person that the first witness had gone to school with, as well as Holyfield. All four of them walked into the bar together.

Both the first and second witnesses described how less than an hour later the two of them went outside together and walked down the street to smoke. A few minutes later, according to the second witness, they saw a group of people running from the direction of the bar.

Advertise with us

They decided to walk back to the car and “all of a sudden” Holyfield was behind them, walking with them, according to the affidavit.

The second witness said that they sensed that “something wasn’t right” with the way Holyfield was acting, explaining to police that as they walked further down Carson Street and people started calming down, Holyfield was still trying to leave quickly.

Holyfield then apparently told the first witness that he was going to look for a friend before disappearing down a side street. The witnesses continued on to the car and waited for him while trying to call him, but the calls did not go through.

He eventually reappeared and the first witness drove Holyfield to his mother’s before driving to the second witness’ apartment for the night.

When the surveillance footage was released to the public, the first witness said that Holyfield called from an unknown number and asked if they had seen the video. The first witness and Holyfield then made plans to go to police headquarters.

Both witnesses were able to identify Holyfield and the other three individuals entering the bar from a picture from the footage and identify Holyfield from a selection of photos.