A former U.S. Navy nuclear engineer who had worked at the Bettis Atomic Power Laboratory in West Mifflin has been charged with trying to sell nuclear submarine secrets for $100,000 to a foreign power after an undercover investigation by the Pittsburgh FBI.
Agents arrested Jonathan Toebbe and his wife, Diana Toebbe, in West Virginia on Sunday after he had placed a memory card at a pre-arranged dead drop in Jefferson County, W.Va., according to the FBI and the Justice Department.
The Toebbes, who live in Annapolis, Md., are in U.S. custody and face initial appearance hearings Tuesday in the Northern District of West Virginia on espionage-related charges.
No lawyers were listed for them in court records.
The FBI said Mr. Toebbe, 42, tried to sell information pertaining to the design of nuclear reactors for Virginia-class submarines, dropping off top-secret data at four dead-drop locations in West Virginia, central Pennsylvania and eastern Virginia.
He thought he was dealing with a representative of a foreign government, but his contact was really an undercover FBI agent, according to an affidavit by Justin Van Tromp, a counterintelligence agent in the Pittsburgh FBI field office.
Read More
Mr. Toebbe, who began employment with the U.S. government in 2012, worked on naval nuclear propulsion projects for the Navy and had been assigned to the Reactor Engineering Division, which does research on reducing reactor plant noise. He had also been assigned to the Bettis lab, which works exclusively on nuclear power projects for the Navy.
"During one or both of these assignments, Jonathan Toebbe had access to the U.S. Navy information passed in both the physical letter to Country 1 as well as the electronic U.S. Navy information passed in the dead drops on June 26, 2021, and August 28, 2021," the FBI said.
The FBI said Mr. Toebbe dropped off secret information at locations in West Virginia, Pennsylvania and Virginia before the final drop at a second West Virginia location.
The case began in December 2020 when an FBI office in the unnamed foreign country — "Country 1" in the affidavit — received a package that representatives from the country had received in April 2020 with a return address in Pittsburgh.
The package contained U.S. Navy documents, a letter of introduction and an SD memory card containing specific instructions on how the foreign government should respond using an encrypted communication platform.
In the letter, the sender indicated he wanted to sell Navy printouts, digital media files containing technical data, operations manuals and performance reports for nuclear reactors on Virginia-class subs.
The letter requested the transmission of the data to the foreign government's military intelligence agency.
"I apologize for this poor translation into your language," the sender wrote. "Please forward this letter to your military intelligence agency. I believe this information will be of great value to your nation. This is not a hoax.”
The sender identified himself in the encrypted communications as "Alice."
The FBI began an undercover operation on Dec. 26, 2020, with an agent posing as a representative of the foreign country using the name "Bob."
In detailed communications from that point on, "Bob" agreed to pay Mr. Toebbe thousands of dollars in cryptocurrency for the information he was offering.
As part of the operation, in May 2021 the FBI placed a signal on a building in Washington, D.C. associated with the foreign country as a sign of trust for "Alice" to observe when he was in town for the Memorial Day weekend.
The following month, the FBI sent $10,000 in cryptocurrency to "Alice" as a "sign of good faith."
The undercover agent then emailed "Alice" to provide location for the first dead drop of data in Jefferson County, W.Va. to occur on June 26 with the understanding that "Alice" would be paid $20,000.
“I understand your instructions and am ready to move forward," replied "Alice."
On June 26, agents were watching as Mr. Toebbe and Diana Toebbe, a teacher at a private school in Annapolis, arrived at the location for the drop. Diana Toebbe was acting as a lookout, the FBI said.
After the couple left, agents recovered an SD card wrapped in plastic and placed inside "two slices of bread on a half of a peanut butter sandwich" inside a plastic bag.
The FBI then set up a second drop for July 31, this time in south-central Pennsylvania. Agents watched Mr. Toebbe and his wife drive from Annapolis to the location, where Mr. Toebbe made the drop, according to the affidavit. Again, Diana appeared to be a lookout.
Agents saw Mr. Toebbe remove a Ziploc bag from his pocket and put it in a container, then remove a written message the FBI had placed inside for him.
After the couple left, agents recovered an SD card hidden in a sealed Band-Aid wrapper inside the Ziploc bag.
The SD card contained a message from "Alice" that said, "You can not imagine my relief at finding your letter just where you told me to look! Indeed, this has been a long journey and I am very happy to have a reliable professional partner in you. ...Thank you for taking the risks you have to build the mutual trust we need to move forward."
Agents set up another drop for Aug. 28 in eastern Virginia. This time Mr. Toebbe went alone, the FBI said. Agents recovered another SD card concealed in a chewing gum package and paid "Alice" $70,000.
In a note to his handler, Mr. Toebbe assured the contact that "only one other person I know is aware of our special relationship, and I trust that person absolutely.” Agents said that he was referring to his wife.
"Alice" also wrote that, "One day, when it is safe, perhaps two old friends will have a chance to stumble into each other at a cafe, share a bottle of wine and laugh over stories of their shared exploits."
The FBI then arranged for a final drop in West Virginia that led to the arrests on Sunday.
The case will be prosecuted in West Virginia by lawyers from the Justice Department's national security division along with prosecutors from the Northern District of West Virginia and Jessica Lieber Smolar, an assistant U.S. attorney in the Pittsburgh U.S. attorney's office.
According to their Facebook pages, the Toebbes are originally from Southern California and have two children.
The Colorado Sun newspaper said Mr. Toebbe had been a science teacher at a private high school in Denver from 2005 to 2008, while Diana taught there from 2005 until 2012.
The Navy said that Mr. Toebbe joined the service in 2012 in Colorado, studied at Officer Training Command in Rhode Island and then worked as a nuclear engineering officer in Virginia and Pittsburgh. He became a lieutenant in 2016 and left active duty in 2017. He had been a human resources officer in the reserves until he left the Navy in December 2020.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.