A federal judge on Tuesday sent the former controller for an electrical contracting company in Butler County to federal prison for six years for embezzling close to $1.5 million over a decade.

U.S. District Judge J. Nicholas Ranjan imposed that term on Paul Harmon, 64, departing upwardly from the sentence recommended even by the U.S. attorney's office.

Such moves are relatively rare for federal judges, who in white-collar cases typically fashion sentences that fall between ranges argued for by defense lawyers and prosecutors.

In this case, Harmon's lawyer, Lyle Dresbold, asked for probation, saying his client suffers from health problems and has otherwise lived a crime-free life.

Advertise with us

Assistant U.S. Attorney Eric Olshan requested a sentence in the guideline range of 33 to 41 months.

Judge Ranjan gave him 72 months, followed by three years of probation.

Harmon had pleaded guilty in January to wire fraud in connection with the thefts from Fuellgraf Electric Co. in Butler, where he was the controller for more than 40 years, and an affiliated company, Technical Management Associates. The companies supplied electricians and electrical services to industrial and commercial clients in Pennsylvania and Florida.

Harmon had day-to-day control over Fuellgraf's finances and internal records. He also had check-writing authority for its bank accounts.

From October 2008 until he was fired in December 2018, Harmon stole nearly $1.5 million and manipulated the books to hide the thefts.

Advertise with us

Prosecutors said he used a variety of schemes: He caused the company to issue more than $470,000 in duplicate or inflated payroll disbursements to himself; he initiated electronic payments of about $500,000 towards his personal credit card balances; he issued about $10,000 in corporate checks to pay his credit card bills; he issued nearly $80,000 in corporate checks to himself, and he misappropriated about $200,000 in corporate checks written to cash.

Harmon also admitted that he issued Fuellgraf checks to PM Accounting, a fake entity he created, totaling another $200,000, for purported accounting services on behalf of Fuellgraf for work that was never done.

To hide what he was doing, Harmon created hundreds of false entries in the Fuellgraf books.

Harmon had been trusted at Fuellgraf to the point where he acted without any direct oversight from Fuellgraf owners.

Mr. Olshan said he took advantage of that trust to fleece the company systematically, stealing about $100,000 a year for many years until he was finally caught and fired. He also said Harmon cannot claim his thefts were a one-time aberration or lapse in judgment, as white-collar criminals often do, since he stole over nearly a decade, used at least six different schemes and carefully hid his actions.

Advertise with us

"In short, the defendant saw what he thought was a low-risk way to take advantage of his employer, and it worked for a significant period of time," Mr. Olshan wrote in sentencing papers. "The egregiousness of the defendant’s crime of opportunity cannot be overstated."

Mr. Dresbold said his client had gone to work for Fuellgraf right after graduating from the University of Pennsylvania in 1979 and worked honestly until 2009. In that year, Harmon needed to cover medical expenses and was heavily medicated due to severe pain, Mr. Dresbold said. He said Harmon has suffered from a ruptured disc, causing nerve pain that required powerful pain opioid medications. Mr. Dresbold said his client also has benign tumors in his neck, diabetes, hypertension, chronic back pain and other medical problems.

He said Harmon no longer takes opiates because they cause his thinking to be unclear.

Because of his health problems and the medications, he began stealing for the first time in 2009, Mr. Dresbold said. At first, he stole a small amount with the intent of paying it back. But he didn't stop.

"Instead, his actions spiraled out of control, resulting in an unjustifiable amount of fraud," Mr. Dresbold wrote.

Advertise with us

He still argued for probation, however, saying Harmon's health conditions contributed to his "poor decision making." He also said his client has already suffered from his actions.

"He lost his career, the respect of his family and friends, his earning potential, and self-respect," he wrote.

But Judge Ranjan rejected the probation request and imposed a term far above even the high end of what the prosecution wanted. The judge said that the sentencing guidelines understated the seriousness of the crime, especially the breach of trust that Fuellgraf placed in Harmon over four decades.

In addition to the prison term, the judge placed Harmon on probation for three years after he is released and ordered him to pay $1,466,456 in restitution.

Harmon had most recently been working part-time at a Butler bait shop.