A Pittsburgh man who owned a 5-foot alligator and other critters in his Beechview home was convicted Friday of 16 charges of neglect of animals and one count of recklessly endangering another person.

Mark McGowan, 46, appeared before Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Thomas Flaherty in a bench trial where witnesses attested to the conditions in which he kept his animals, which included three alligators, a Burmese python, a rattlesnake, a Nile monitor lizard, and iguanas.

He was acquitted Thursday of animal cruelty but returned to the courtroom Friday morning for the other 37 charges, many of which were summary offenses. Mr. McGowan was sentenced to two years probation, during which time he is not allowed to own an animal or reside in a residence with any animals.

The charges stem from when police in 2019 investigated Mr. McGowan’s home after one of his alligators, named Chomp, was seen roaming the streets near Sebring and Rutherford avenues and had to be captured by city police and animal control officers.

Advertise with us

Investigators at the time said they found several dead animals, including a turtle, in his residence. Prosecutors have said that he kept the creatures in an unsuitable environment, while defense attorneys assured that Mr. McGowan was an experienced breeder and vendor of wildlife.

Mr. McGowan, who appeared in court with his long hair tied back and wearing black Crocs shoes, testified that he used Chomp to educate children and show people what a full-grown alligator looked like.

“He was my pet, like my dog,” he told the court. “I loved him. He was my pet.”

Chomp was kept in a pond downstairs in his home, and Mr. McGowan said the pond was cleaned weekly. During cleanings, Chomp would be kept in the kitchen and secured behind a plastic gate. It was during one of those cleanings that the animal escaped the house.

The gator posed no threat to anyone because he was “extremely domesticated,” Mr. McGowan claimed, “like a dog or a cat,” adding that he was very friendly and never bit anyone.

Advertise with us

Upon cross examination, prosecutor Mike Siegert, asked if Mr. McGowan agreed that Chomp was still a wild animal despite how long he was held in domesticity.

“He’s an alligator, sir,” Mr. McGowan replied. “He was not born in the wild.” He went on to say that he believed Chomp was not a “predator” because he was never fed live animals, so he didn’t equate movement with food.

But when the prosecutor pointed out that the gator hissed at the man who spotted Chomp while he was out of the house, Mr. McGowan said he would have never gone after the man and his dog. “That was a scared mechanism, sir,” he said.

Asked why he didn’t report Chomp missing, he said he was overwhelmed. “Honestly, I did not know what to do,” he said. “I went into a panic.”

Mr. McGowan was a popular figure in the regional reptile enthusiast community, his friend, Chelsey Mering, testified. “Prior to this case, everyone got along with him and supported him,” she said. But since he was charged, people “kind of turned their backs on him.”

Advertise with us

A reptile lover herself, Ms. Mering said she had been to hundreds of expositions for the animals and said Mr. McGowan was a frequent vendor and had even run his own expo in Erie.

She testified that Mr. McGowan’s animals were always clean and well taken care of, but an expert witness from the Pittsburgh Zoo and PPG Aquarium told the court that animals should have their blood or fecal matter examined before they’re determined to be healthy, rather than a visual examination.

In closing, defense attorney Julia Gitleman said Chomp posed no more threat than an unloaded gun. “Just because an alligator can be dangerous, doesn’t mean ... the alligator was dangerous or did create a dangerous circumstance,” she said, calling Mr. McGowan negligent rather than reckless.

But Mr. Siegert said there was a “huge difference,” and unless Chomp had no tail and no teeth, “he is certainly not akin to an unloaded gun.”

Mr. McGowan knew Chomp escaped and took no action, Mr. Siegert continued. “I would characterize that conduct as reckless rather than negligent. It’s not like a poodle escaped and the defendant failed to notify authorities.”

Advertise with us

On the charges where Mr. McGowan was found not guilty, Judge Flaherty said the prosecutors failed to meet their burden to prove that the animals were truly neglected.

Correction, 6:55 p.m., July 9, 2021: A previous version of this story misidentified the prosecutor.

Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter: @MickStinelli