The federal judge presiding over the death penalty case of Robert Bowers on Thursday rejected numerous defense efforts to suppress evidence from FBI searches of Mr. Bowers' house, vehicle and electronic devices.

U.S. District Judge Donetta Ambrose denied all the motions except one regarding an email account, which she said she'll hold in abeyance until she hears an argument about it.

Mr. Bowers faces the federal death penalty in the October 2018 massacre of 11 worshippers at the Tree of Life synagogue.

The defense team — two public defenders and a California anti-death penalty activist — have challenged the granting of various search warrants by U.S. Magistrate Judge Robert Mitchell in the aftermath of the shootings.

Advertise with us

In one motion, the lawyers contend that the affidavits for the searches of Mr. Bowers' home and vehicle failed to establish probable cause, lacked specifics and that the searches were conducted after the warrants expired.

Judge Ambrose rejected the motion. "Contrary to [Bowers'] characterization, the warrants did not afford executing agents unbridled or unfettered discretion to rummage" for evidence, the judge ruled.

She said the warrants for searches limited permission to listed items and refer to motive, which was part of the specific crime at issue in that Mr. Bowers is charged with hate crimes in targeting Jews. A second warrant for the house was limited to evidence of bomb-making, she said, and a third warrant for the home was similar to the first. "The warrants thus distinguished the specified items from the multitude of items unrelated to defined criminal behavior; they did not authorize a wholesale, exploratory rummaging," Judge Ambrose wrote.

A second motion challenged an FBI warrant for medical records filed on Feb. 10, 2020, pertaining to medical exams by two doctors in 2015 and 2017 for a Department of Transportation Commercial Driver's License application. Mr. Bowers was a truck driver.

Mr. Bowers' lawyers said the warrant lacked specifics and was an "illegal general warrant." But Judge Ambrose said the warrant was sufficiently limited in scope. She noted that the FBI said in an affidavit that the government will be required to prove that Mr. Bowers acted willfully and that his "mental health will be at issue in this prosecution at both the guilt and penalty phases.” She said the affidavit was “not so lacking in indicia of probable cause as to make belief in its existence objectively unreasonable.” She said there are no grounds to suppress.

Advertise with us

The defense had also argued that search warrants for Mr. Bowers' email accounts failed to establish probable cause. Judge Ambrose largely rejected that contention, too. She said the FBI's affidavit for the search laid out the details of the shooting and made note that during the attack Mr. Bowers "made audible statements regarding genocide, his desire to kill Jewish people and that Jewish people needed to die."

The affidavit further recounted evidence that Mr. Bowers made various anti-Semitic statements in online posts prior to the attacks. Judge Ambrose said the fact that the affidavit does not explicitly provide sources for each fact "does not negate the reasonable inferences to be drawn from the totality of the information."

She said evidence recovered from the search of one email account, ODGPhone@gmail.com, will not be suppressed, nor will the recovery of Mr. Bowers' mobile phone equipment identity number.

The defense also challenged the FBI seizure of a second email account, onedingo@gmail.com, from December 2007 to March 2008. The judge said she won't rule on that motion until she hears an argument.