This story was updated at 10:40 a.m. on Thursday, July 1, 2021.

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Thursday upheld two Arizona voting restrictions that a lower court had said discriminated against minority voters.

Justice Samuel Alito wrote the opinion in the 6-3 ruling, which divided the court along ideological lines.

The court was considering the shield provided by the landmark Voting Rights Act, first passed in 1965 to forbid laws that result in discrimination based on race.

Advertise with us

The cases involved two voting regulations from Arizona that are in common use across the country. One throws out the ballots of those who vote in the wrong precinct. The other restricts who may collect ballots cast early for delivery to polling places, a practice then-President Donald Trump denounced as “ballot harvesting.”

But the greater impact could be how the Voting Rights Act relates to an outpouring of new laws enacted by Republican-led state legislatures that have changed voting procedures, as well as on the drawing of congressional and legislative districts following the 2020 Census.

Reacting to Trump’s false claims of widespread fraud, Republican-led legislatures are racing to enact laws that cut back on easements to voting implemented in part because of the coronavirus pandemic.

Even if investigations by Trump’s Justice Department and other Republican officials failed to substantiate the charges, they argue restrictions are needed to assure public confidence in election outcomes.

Democratic lawyers are already challenging changes in the South and Midwest. Attorney General Merrick Garland has filed a complaint about changes made to Georgia’s voting laws.

Advertise with us

The liberal Brennan Center for Justices said at least 880 bills proposing election law changes have been introduced in 49 states. Of these, at least 28 bills with expansive provisions have been signed into law in 14 states.

In 2013, the Supreme Court made it harder for civil rights groups to challenge such changes. It effectively eliminated the requirement that states proven to have discriminated against minorities in the past receive advance approval from a panel of federal judges or the Justice Department before changing their laws.

The court was examining a part of the voter protection law called Section 2, which was amended in 1982 to prohibit any voting practice that “results in a denial or abridgment of the right of any citizen of the United States to vote on account of race or color.”

It most often has been employed against jurisdictions that rig election lines to dilute minority voters’ impact. But after the decision in Shelby County v. Holder, civil rights groups are using it to challenge restrictions they say place a heavier burden on minority groups.

Lower courts are working through how to apply the law in these new challenges.

Advertise with us

In Arizona, Democrats challenged the two provisions on out of precinct voting and ballot collection. A district judge held a trial and upheld them. A panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit agreed with that decision on a 2-1 vote.

But a larger panel of the 9th Circuit stepped in, and said that the way the provisions were applied in Arizona disproportionately affected Black and Hispanic voters.

Those judges said that the state changed locations of voting places more often in minority communities, leading to voter confusion, and that the rates of discarded out of precinct votes were far higher in Arizona than in other states. Arizona throws out the entire ballot, even if some races — governor, for instance — are not affected by the voter’s precinct location.

Democrats said that between 2008 and 2016, Arizona discarded 38,335 out of precinct ballots in general elections — all of which were cast by registered, eligible voters.

The judges said the ban on collecting ballots was intentionally passed to harm minority voters, who they said were more likely to be homebound or disabled and also lacking reliable means to vote in person. Native Americans had in the past been served by community or political leaders who collected early vote ballots, the court said.

Advertise with us

“There is no evidence of any fraud in the long history of third-party ballot collection in Arizona,” Judge William A. Fletcher wrote. The court’s 6-5 ruling that the discrimination was intentional is a rarity in federal court reviews of state actions.

Arizona countered that it makes exceptions for ballot-handling by family and household members and caregivers and that nothing prevents Arizona from taking action to prevent fraud.

In an unusual letter to the Supreme Court, the Biden administration somewhat reluctantly agreed that Arizona’s laws do not violate Section 2.

The cases are Brnovich v. Democratic National Committee and Arizona Republican Party v. DNC.