Three years after beating two men to death in a basement and lighting a house on fire, Vincent Smith, aged 61, has been sentenced to 26 to 52 years in prison.

Smith, who was sentenced on Wednesday in Common Pleas Court, pleaded guilty in April to two counts of voluntary manslaughter and four counts of arson-related charges. The manslaughter charges resulted from the deaths of his friend Steven Pariser, 71, of Point Breeze, and John Robert Van Dyke, 54, of Swissvale.

The string of events leading up to Smith’s arrest started on Feb. 21, 2018, when Smith got into a fight with Pariser and Van Dyke at Pariser’s home over marijuana.

Smith told the men that he was going to steal the substance from them, and Pariser — with whom he had been living intermittently — began to attack him, according to Smith.

Advertise with us

It escalated quickly from there.

Smith confessed to police that he picked up a hammer and used it to hit Pariser on the head before pushing him down the stairs and into the basement, according to previous reporting. When Van Dyke tried to stop him, Smith pushed him down the stairs as well.

Smith followed them into the basement and bashed their heads against the steps and the floor until they went limp.

The next day, Van Dyke’s brother filed a missing person report after their mother had visited Van Dyke’s house and found his car missing.

Swissvale police were able to find Van Dyke’s location through an emergency ping to his phone on Feb. 26, 2018. It led them to Pariser’s rowhouse.

Advertise with us

When no one answered the door, they forcibly entered the building through the back basement door, finding the room dark and filled with trash. When they made their way to the first floor, they noticed a shadowy movement and announced their arrival again.

A voice from someone they could not see said “Steven’s not here,” according to the affidavit.

They realized the voice was coming from the second floor and saw a man, later identified as Smith, toss lit matches onto the floor. A strong blaze ignited, quickly traveling down the stairs and forcing the officers to leave the building. Smith had put lighter fluid on the floor in an attempt to commit suicide.

However, firemen were able to get Smith out of the house.

Police later found the bodies of Pariser and Van Dyke buried under trash and debris in the basement. Both bodies had blunt-force head trauma.

Advertise with us

Smith previously has been found guilty of carrying a firearm without a license, harassment, stalking and felony counts of drug possession, among other charges, according to previous reporting. He was also charged with luring a child in 2014, but the charge was later changed to simple assault.

Boyce Buchanan: bbuchanan@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BuchananBoyce.