Will Gates, 79, stood outside his home Monday afternoon in McDonald, Washington County, for nearly 10 minutes talking to his next-door neighbor James Garove — the first time the two had a conversation since Mr. Gates and his wife moved to the neighborhood last April.
Mr. Gates was unaware it was the last conversation he would have with Mr. Garove. Minutes after their casual conversation ended, shots were fired inside Mr. Garove’s home in the 200 block of Valley Street. According to Pennsylvania State Police Trooper Forrest Allison, a preliminary investigation revealed that Mr. Garove had shot and killed his ex-wife, Christina Carr, 27, and her mother, Suzanne Faingnaert, 57, before shooting himself.
“[Mr. Garove] seemed fine when we were talking. He was calm and he didn’t have any weapons on him,” Mr. Gates said Thursday. “As we were talking, [Mr. Garove] kept looking at his watch, and I remember because it had just turned 6:01 p.m. and he seemed like he had something to do at that time.”
Moments after their chat, and before he could make it inside his house, Mr. Gates said he heard a loud “bang, bang, bang” as gunshots went off next door.
“I thought the sound was coming from the woods behind our house at first,” Mr. Gates said. “It’s just so sad. I’m thankful I didn’t get struck by one bullet that came through a side window.”
The small neighborhood is usually quiet, said neighbor Judi Fulmer, 74, who has lived there since the 1970s.
Read More
“I just can’t believe something like this happened. I haven’t seen anything like it during my time living here,” Ms. Fulmer said.
Court records show Mr. Garove and Ms. Carr had a tumultuous relationship, and close neighbors confirmed the two had an on-again, off-again union. Both lived at the Valley Street address. They share a 6-year-old son who, according to neighbors, was not home during Monday’s shooting. Ms. Carr’s mother, Ms. Faingnaert, lived on Fifth Street in McDonald.
Prior to the shooting, Mr. Garove had parked a small trailer in the back of his home and said he planned to move some of his items from inside the home Monday, Mr. Gates said.
About a year ago, Ms. Carr moved into the Valley Street apartment and Mr. Garove had been living on and off in the apartment since then, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette news partner KDKA confirmed.
Ms. Carr filed for divorce in 2017 and also filed a petition for a protection-from-abuse order against Mr. Garove in September 2020. The order did not hold because the two got back together soon after it was filed, according to Ms. Carr’s friend and Mr. Gates’ wife, Carol Gates.
“[Mr. Garove] seemed nice, and I never heard them arguing, but you never know what goes on behind closed doors,” Mrs. Gates said.
In the request for a temporary protection-from-abuse order, Ms. Carr said she suggested that Mr. Garove find somewhere else to stay because things were not working out between them. Mr. Garove got upset and accused her of seeing someone else, court records show.
Ms. Carr said Mr. Garove took off in his truck and came back drunk, court records show. He then demanded she reimburse him for money he put into fixing her car. When she told him she didn’t have the money to give him, that’s when she says he threatened to break into her car and take the parts that he paid for.
The PFA also said Mr. Garove grabbed a bag full of empty bottles and hit Ms. Carr in the mouth, giving her a swollen lip. She then called police and Mr. Garove left in his truck again, according to the PFA document.
“I still can’t believe it; I have gone to bed every night thinking about Christina and her mom,” Mrs. Gates said Thursday. “It’s awful, it’s just awful. She was a very nice girl and just so young. She would help anybody.”
Lacretia Wimbley: lwimbley@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1510 or on Twitter @Wimbleyjourno.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.