A Westmoreland County jury on Thursday found former Pirates pitcher Felipe Vazquez guilty of 15 counts, including statutory sexual assault, corruption of minors and child pornography.

The verdict came on the fourth day of testimony after four hours of deliberation.

Mr. Vazquez was found not guilty of 10 counts of unlawful contact or communication with a minor, which were connected to pornographic photos exchanged between Mr. Vazquez, 29, and the teenage victim.

He was also found guilty on charges of sexual abuse of children and corruption of minors.

Advertise with us

Mr. Vazquez remained generally unmoved as the verdict was read. His attorney, Gary Gerson, said the athlete was hoping to be acquitted and continue his career.

Mr. Gerson guessed that contemporary photos of the teen may have convinced the jury that Mr. Vazquez was unreasonable to believe she was 18.

“When you have a child victim, it’s a heavy lift,” he said. “Especially when the child victim is still a child.”

Mr. Gerson delivered his closing argument that day by stirring doubt about the credibility of the victim and the state troopers who interviewed and arrested Mr. Vazquez, noting that the only law enforcement officer who recorded the defendant was from Florida.

As with his opening statement, Mr. Gerson took much of his final moments to convince the jury that the victim is a habitual liar who used “reverse grooming” to convince Mr. Vazquez that she was an adult, saying his client was in “way over his head in this relationship.”

Advertise with us

He sought to paint the victim as a manipulator who infantilized herself to her mother and law enforcement while acting extremely mature with Mr. Vazquez.

“If you think she left that house looking like a 12-year-old or a 13-year-old, then convict him.” Mr. Gerson said. “But she didn’t.”

Westmoreland County Assistant District Attorney James Lazar rebutted that idea and focused much of his closing on the contradictions in Mr. Vazquez’s story, pointing out that the baseball star claimed to have casual relationships with about 50 women. Mr. Lazar took issue with the idea that a teen could create a facade capable of making her seem like one of those adults.

“Somehow, she’s able to put on such a face that she walks into a world that he lives in every day,” he said.

He continued: “I suggest to you he’s bored with the groupies. He’s had all that.”

Advertise with us

There was no credible evidence, Mr. Lazar told the jury, to suggest Mr. Vazquez believed she was anything other than a child. He also noted that when Mr. Vazquez first brought up the victim’s ID during a police interview, he called it a “fake ID.”

Mr. Vazquez also told the jury that his pregame routine consisted of napping in the Pirates clubhouse during the first few innings of the game. But phone records showed he had been exchanging sexual messages with the victim during the beginning of at least one game at PNC Park.

“I don’t know what he does on the couch in that clubhouse,”  Mr. Lazar said, “but it isn’t napping.”

Earlier Thursday, Mr. Lazar cross-examined Mr. Vazquez about his alleged sexual assault of the teenage girl, with the defendant contradicting testimony from prior witnesses.

Mr. Vazquez and his attorneys focused on his opinion that the girl had a mature figure and attitude as Mr. Vazquez explained that he believed she was 17 when they first met outside her Westmoreland County home. The girl was actually 13.

Advertise with us

“Ever since I saw her that first day, when I saw her coming down, that was the type of woman I wanted in my life,” he recalled thinking at the time.

Pressed by the prosecution about what he meant when he described her walk as “sassy,” Mr. Lazar asked Mr. Vazquez to show the jury what he meant.

Mr. Vazquez shook his head, then said it was like a model on a runway or a woman strutting through a ring holding a card with the upcoming round number during a boxing match. “I don’t want to walk like a woman, that’s what I’m trying to say.”

But when the judge allowed the question to go forward, Mr. Vazquez stood in front of the jury with his arms out, hands splayed at waist level and took a few steps while swinging his hips.

“Let the record reflect that Mr. Vazquez was sashaying in front of the jury,” Mr. Gerson said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Vazquez maintained that she misled him and sent him a fake ID to seem older than she was, which the girl has denied.

Charges in Missouri and Florida that are connected to him communicating with the same girl are also pending.

In addition to contradicting prior testimony from the alleged victim and Pennsylvania State Troopers, he admitted to making false statements under oath when he said at a prior proceeding that he didn’t drive to her house to have sex.

“Are you telling the truth now?” Mr. Gerson asked.

“Yes,” Mr. Vazquez responded.

Advertise with us

When he received a text from the girl’s mom saying that she was underage, he said, he didn’t believe it was real.

It was not clear if the verdict would cause Mr. Vazquez to be deported to his home country of Venezuela. He is set to be sentenced in 90 days, but Mr. Gerson said he may move for an expedited sentencing.

Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1869 and on Twitter @MickStinelli.