A federal court jury on Wednesday acquitted a former New Castle police officer accused of using excessive force against a drunk suspect during an arrest three years ago in a New Castle apartment.
Ronald Williams was charged with one count of depriving Perry Lawry of his civil rights by beating him.
The jury deliberated about an hour before reaching its not guilty decision.
The trial was the first held in U.S. District Court here since February 2020; trials had been suspended because of COVID-19 but have resumed now that restrictions are being lifted.
The key piece of evidence in the case was a cellphone video. It shows Officer Williams grabbing Mr. Lawry by the hair and slamming his face into the floor four times while another officer attempts to handcuff him.
On the video, Officer Williams is heard telling Mr. Lawry, “I’m going to [expletive] kill you” as he lifts Mr. Lawry by his hair from behind and slams his head to the floor.
Read More
Testimony began Tuesday with the other officer, Pete Mendicino, telling the jury that Mr. Lawry was no longer resisting when Officer Williams assaulted him.
In his closing argument on Wednesday morning, Assistant U.S. Attorney Eric Olshan said Officer Williams used too much force and then tried to cover up what he did by writing in his report that Mr. Lawry was “crawling” toward knives on a nearby counter.
Officer Mendicino said Mr. Lawry had earlier run toward the knives as the two struggled before Officer Williams had arrived on the scene.
But by the time of the alleged assault, he said, Mr. Lawry was under control. Mr. Olshan said Officer Williams’ use of force was unreasonable in that scenario.
“This was raw violence,” he said.
He said Officer Williams is seen on the video “rearing up, back down, rearing up, back down,” repeatedly slamming Mr. Lawry’s face into the hardwood floor until he stops moving. He said the fact that Officer Williams is heard saying “I’m going to kill you” is an indication of his intent.
“These are not police commands,” he said. “He didn’t say ‘show me your hands’ or ‘stop resisting.’”
Officer Williams did not take the stand in his own defense.
But his lawyer, Stephen Colafella, portrayed his client as a hero. He said Officer Williams was responding to a domestic violence call and arrived to help Officer Mendicino, who Mr. Colafella suggested was not up to the job of handling Mr. Lawry. He said Officer Williams saw his colleague struggling with Mr. Lawry and took action to assist. He said Officer Mendicino was lucky that Officer Williams was there.
He also said Mr. Lawry, who is about 5 feet, 7 inches tall and 170 pounds, fought the two officers despite a huge difference in size and weight. Officer Mendicino is 6-foot-2 and 200 pounds and Officer Williams is 6-foot-4 and 300 pounds.
Mr. Colafella said Mr. Lawry absorbed Officer Mendicino’s knee strikes and later at least two stuns from Officer Williams’ Taser but still kept resisting.
“He just won’t quit,” he said.
So Officer Williams, a 10-year veteran, took the action seen in the video to subdue him, yelling “Enough!”
“He was trying to get this guy to stop fighting,” Mr. Colafella said.
Mr. Colafella also told the jury that “it doesn’t matter” what Officer Williams wrote in his report of the incident, which Mr. Olshan said contains lies, because the jurors have the video.
Mr. Colafella acknowledged that the recording is “disturbing” to watch and hear.
He said “force isn’t fun to watch” but sometimes it’s necessary in police work.
Officer Williams was indicted in 2019 in connection with the April 23, 2018, incident.
Officer Mendicino responded that day to a dispatch call for a domestic dispute after Mr. Lawry’s girlfriend said he was drunk and had assaulted her juvenile son.
Officer Mendicino said he found Mr. Lawry lying on the kitchen floor, drunk and incoherent. The officer said he grabbed Mr. Lawry and lifted him to his feet. He said Mr. Lawry then pulled away from him and ran toward a counter with large knives on it.
Officer Mendicino grabbed him and the two grappled, toppling the kitchen island and landing on the floor. Officer Mendicino said he kneed Mr. Lawry in the torso multiple times to get him under control.
At that moment, Officer Williams arrived, ran up the stairs and joined the fight.
Officer Williams used his Taser several times to no effect. The officers eventually subdued Mr. Lawry and had him on his knees.
Officer Mendicino had put one handcuff on Mr. Lawry’s right wrist and was trying to grab his left hand. Officer Williams was on top of Mr. Lawry and had his knee in his back. At that point, Officer Williams grabbed Mr. Lawry’s hair from behind and smacked his face against the floor.
After the third strike, Officer Mendicino said, “Ronnie, I got it,” an indication for Officer Williams to stop. But Officer Williams delivers one more blow after that, the video shows.
Audio from the cellphone video, shot by the juvenile son, records the thumping sounds of Mr. Lawry’s face impacting the floor and the son saying, “Don’t kill him!” and later “Jesus Christ. I think he’s dead” after Mr. Lawry stops moving.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.