A former nursing aide was sentenced Tuesday to seven consecutive life terms and an additional 20 years in federal prison after confessing to injecting lethal doses of insulin into frail, elderly veterans in her care at a West Virginia Veterans Affairs hospital.
“You’re the monster that no one sees coming,” U.S. District Judge Thomas Kleeh told Reta Mays before announcing the sentence in a courtroom in Clarksburg, W.Va., dismissing her lawyers’ arguments that she deserved leniency because of a long history of medical and mental health issues stemming from her childhood and military service.
Many defendants who appear in his courtroom, particularly veterans such as she, have led hard lives in West Virginia, the judge told Mays, 46, “but you’re not special. None of these folks are killers, let alone serial killers.”
As the sentencing took place, VA Inspector General Michael Missal released a blistering investigative report that concluded that cascading failures by the Louis Johnson Medical Center, the Clarksburg hospital that hired Mays in 2015, enabled the nursing aide to target patients for nearly a year.
Mr. Missal’s 100-page report cited “serious, pervasive, and deep-rooted clinical and administrative failures” that allowed the murders to go undetected as Mays injected patient after patient with insulin, from July 2017 through June 2018, that she was not authorized to administer, leading to their dying of severe hypoglycemia, or low blood sugar.
“Somebody should have been asking questions and looking into it, and they did not do that,” Mr. Missal said at a news conference Tuesday.
The wives, daughters, sons and other family members of Mays’s eight victims — all but one of whom died — gave wrenching testimony Tuesday about the pain she inflicted.
Melanie Proctor, whose father, retired Army Sgt. Felix McDermott, was 82 when he was murdered, called him a “proud Army veteran and ornery character who would give anybody a helping hand.” She said Mays had “taken away any faith in the VA system that my dad held in high esteem.”
“You took some of the greatest men of our time and preyed on them when they were at their weakest,” Ms. Proctor said, “and for that you are a coward.”
Mays, a veteran who deployed to Iraq with the Army National Guard from 2003 to 2004, cried as she briefly addressed the court, saying, “I don’t ask anyone for forgiveness because I don’t think I could forgive anyone for doing what I did. I can only say I’m sorry for the pain I caused the families and my family.”
Mr. Missal described “missed opportunities” at all leadership levels that caused a failure to stop Mays, eventually leading investigators to exhume several bodies.
Joined by officials from the U.S. attorney’s office for the Northern District of West Virginia and the FBI, he said there was a three-week period when four veterans died under suspicious circumstances on the hospital’s medical surgical unit, known as 3A.
Mays, who had been assigned to monitor veterans in what are known as one-on-one bedside vigils for patients who need extra attention, initially denied any involvement with the deaths in three interviews with investigators.
She ultimately pleaded guilty in July to seven counts of second-degree murder and one count of assault with intent to commit murder. Her victims were men, almost all of them in their 80s, who had been admitted to the hospital with various ailments of old age, including heart problems and dementia. A few had mild diabetes.
None were about to die, and some were on the verge of being released when Mays, working the overnight shift with little supervision, injected them with insulin she found lying unprotected on medicine carts and in supply rooms, investigators found.
Investigators identified similarities in the deaths: Elderly patients in private rooms were injected in their abdomen and limbs with insulin the hospital had not prescribed — some with multiple shots. Within hours, the veterans’ blood-sugar levels plummeted. Despite those commonalities, the medical staff and those with oversight of hospital procedures failed to identify a pattern for months, the inspector general’s office found.
VA, in a statement, called the case “heartbreaking” and pledged to regain the trust of veterans and their families. The agency said it has made improvements to management and patient care at Clarksburg and will begin an outside review of all cases in which patients with whom Mays had contact had negative outcomes.
VA has reached financial settlements with families of half a dozen victims, paying out about $5 million, it said.
Mays was fired from the hospital in 2019, seven months after being removed from patient care, after it was discovered that she had lied about her qualifications on her resume. Several senior hospital staffers have been reassigned, including the director, Glenn Snider Jr., who now works at a regional office.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.