A 70-year-old Pittsburgh woman alleges in a lawsuit that two city police officers roughly handcuffed her on a false hit-and-run charge from another jurisdiction and sent her to jail, all because she bumped a parked car in Sharpsburg and left a note for the owner before leaving.

Mary Lewin last week sued the two Pittsburgh officers, Benjamin Olsen and Darion Feist, along with a Sharpsburg officer, Jeffrey Hussar, in federal court on civil rights claims.

This is what Ms. Lewin and her lawyer, Joel Sansone, said happened:

Ms. Lewin was backing out of Sacco’s Automotive Services in August 2018 when she hit a parked car, causing minor damage. The owner, Lindsay McKay, wasn’t around. So Ms. Lewin left a note with her insurance information on the windshield. She also waited for 15 minutes to see if the owner would show up. She didn’t, so Ms. Lewin left.

Advertise with us

Ms. McKay contacted her later, and Ms. Lewin gave her the insurance information, after which Ms. Lewin’s insurance accepted liability for the damage, she says.

About three weeks after the incident, Officer Hussar charged her with failure to stop and give information, failure to render aid, and failure to notify police of an accident. He filed the charges even though, in his affidavit of probable cause, he acknowledged that Ms. Lewin left her contact information for Ms. McKay and that Ms. McKay wasn’t at the scene.

“Defendant Hussar knew, or should have known, through the exercise of reasonable caution, that no reasonable basis existed” for charging her, the lawsuit says. The damage to the car didn’t render it unable to be driven, and no one was injured.

Ms. Lewin said no one ever contacted her about the charges. In addition, she said the notice of the preliminary hearing was mailed to the wrong address.

When she didn’t show up for the hearing, a bench warrant was issued for her arrest in October 2018. More than a year later, on Nov. 20, 2019, Ms. Lewin was driving in Oakland when Officers Feist and Olsen pulled her over. They made her get out of the car and walk backward toward them, then “forcefully and aggressively handcuffed” Ms. Lewin and arrested her, the suit alleges. They didn’t tell her the reason.

Advertise with us

“Plaintiff repeatedly informed these Defendants that she had a torn rotator cuff and requested that the handcuffs be loosened, as she was in extreme pain so unbearable that she began to cry,” the suit says.

Ms. Lewin said at no time was she a danger to anyone. The police searched her car, and two more officers arrived at the scene. Eventually, they told her she was wanted for hit and run. They took her to jail, where she was detained for 17 hours, she says.

She said she suffered public humiliation, anxiety and distress as a result of what the officers did.

The complaint lists numerous counts, including malicious prosecution; unreasonable seizure, arrest and imprisonment in violation of the Fourth Amendment; and excessive force under the Fourth Amendment.

A spokesman for the police didn’t immediately respond to a request for comment.