An East Allegheny man on Thursday was sentenced to life in prison in a 2017 killing of another man he suspected of being a drug informant.

Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Jill Rangos sentenced Justin Parrotte, 32, to life without parole — the mandatory sentence for the first-degree murder charge — plus a consecutive 5 to 10 years in prison for gun charges.

Parrotte was convicted in February 2020 during a non-jury trial after he was accused of killing 40-year-old John Miller in 2017 in Spring Garden.

According to a criminal complaint, an unidentified witness told investigators that they had seen Miller purchasing drugs on Phineas Street in the city’s East Allegheny neighborhood.

Advertise with us

Another witness told detectives that Parrotte, identified by the witnesses as “Sosa,” was looking for two informants on the day of the killing, one of whom was named “Johnny.”

Parrotte, toting a .40-caliber handgun, told the witness he believed the man was responsible for a drug raid on Phineas Street, the complaint reads.

The witness told Parrotte she knew the man from buying heroin at the Phineas Street drug house. She met up with Parrotte and Miller that night, and the two men began to go up a set of city steps on Vinial Street, the complaint says.

Parrotte told the woman to wait at the bottom of the steps and watch if anyone was coming, she told police. Immediately after they went up the steps, the witness heard “a lot” of gunshots, she said. Parrotte and Miller were the only two people on the stairs.

Detectives then learned that Parrotte had an active warrant for stealing a .40-caliber handgun. They found that the head-stamp on the casings at the scene matched that of the stamp on the ammunition purchased with the gun.

Advertise with us

When police went to arrest Parrotte, he discarded the handgun, but detectives recovered it and matched it with the stolen .40-caliber.

Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter: @MickStinelli