A 21-year-old Shaler man who admitted to damaging a Pittsburgh police car during the Downtown riots over the killing of George Floyd in Minneapolis was sentenced Wednesday to one day in U.S. custody and six months in a halfway house.
U.S. District Judge Arthur Schwab imposed that term on Brian Bartels and also ordered him to pay $1,000 in restitution. The six-month sentence will be served as part of a three-year term of probation.
Bartels had previously pleaded guilty in September to obstruction of law enforcement during civil disorder.
U.S. prosecutors wanted jail time for Bartels but his lawyer asked for probation.
Law enforcement said Bartels kicked in the windshield of a cruiser and then spray-painted a letter A on it during the May 30 protests. His actions spurred on a crowd to further violence that led to the car being burned and other damage.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Shaun Sweeney said in sentencing papers that Bartels spray-painted the car “in the presence of an agitated crowd” and then smashed parts of the vehicle “in order to make it unusable by the officers who were trying to prevent civil disorder.”
He said Bartels did not directly assault any officers but obstructed them by damaging their car.
Joseph Otte, Bartels’ lawyer, said his client had accepted responsibility for his actions, meeting less than two days later with investigators to explain what he did.
“He expressed remorse and even confusion at his own actions,” Mr. Otte said in sentencing papers.
He told police, “I called my parents on the drive home, and I’m like, ‘I am about to drop a bomb on you. Sorry to ruin your day. Uhhh … I did something stupid at the protest.’”
Mr. Otte said the case “will follow Brian Bartels for the rest of his life. His actions were caught on video and were played tens of thousands of times on local news, national news, and social media. A video of him solemnly turning himself in at the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police Headquarters received over 1.6 million views on Twitter. He was condemned by people on the political right and rebuked by people on the political left. For a moment, he became the face of how not to protest.”
Mr. Otte said Bartels has struggled with mental health issues that likely contributed to his actions in damaging the car.
But he said Bartels is committed to being a different person than the one everyone saw on TV and social media.
He said Bartels is seeking a degree in political science and psychology “so that he can better understand the world and use non-violent means to effect the change he wants.”
Mr. Otte said Bartels has been accepted to complete his bachelor’s degree at Ohio Wesleyan University and will start classes after his federal case is completed.
Bartels is also seeing a therapist.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.