An Allegheny County judge on Thursday dismissed a lawsuit claiming that Pittsburgh City Councilman Ricky Burgess was in violation of the city’s Home Rule Charter.

The lawsuit, filed in December 2019 by community activist Carmen Brown, claimed that Rev. Burgess should be removed from office because, as a tenured professor at the Community College of Allegheny County, he was in violation of section 308 of the city’s charter, which says members of City Council shall not “hold any other office, position or employment in the Government of the United States, the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, the city of Pittsburgh or Allegheny County.”

Common Pleas Judge Joseph M. James, however, cited a similar case in state Supreme Court in which the the court decided that the Pennsylvania House of Representatives has the sole power to impeach elected officials, as stated in Article VI of the Pennsylvania Constitution.

Thus, the provision in the city’s charter that Ms. Brown cites is in conflict with the state constitution and is therefore unconstitutional, according to the opinion.

Advertise with us

Judge James also noted that CCAC is not the type of governmental body prohibited by the city’s charter, as the community college is a separate entity from the county.

In an email Thursday night, Ms. Brown said she planned to appeal the decision.