Three men who were charged with simple assault following a fight at a Marshall-Shadeland gas station last year were found guilty this week of a lesser summary charge of harassment.
The charges stem from a fight at an Exxon station where the men who worked at the station were seen beating two women on a viral video following a confrontation over a refund. The footage resulted in days of protest outside the gas station on Brighton Road, and the location closed before reopening in May under new management.
Following the Monday ruling, Scott Hill, 51, of the North Side, Sukhjinder Sadhra, 36, of Ross and Balkar Singh, 41, of Cheswick were each ordered to pay $300 in fines as well as court costs.
Todd Hollis, the attorney for Jamila Regan, 25, and Ashia Regan, 27, the sisters seen being slapped in the video, said he was disappointed in the ruling but respected the court’s decision. Mr. Hollis said he plans to move forward by suing the men and the gas station in civil court.
“I think the video speaks for itself,” Mr. Hollis said. “You’ve got three grown men who can be seen holding two young women down … smacking them in the back of the head, running them into gas [pumps], dragging them by their braids out the store, punching them in the face throughout what I would consider to be a very long, unnecessary interaction.”
Surveillance, bystander video combo of Exxon assault
Attorneys for the defendants did not immediately respond to request for comment.
Read More
The criminal complaint filed in September 2019 said the sisters had walked into the store and asked for a refund for fuel that spilled from a faulty pump. They demanded their full $17 back for the wasted fuel.
Mr. Sadhra and Mr. Singh, who were the station owners, said there was only a small puddle of gas at the pump. This assessment was later verified by the police.
Police said a review of multiple videos showed one of the women initiated the confrontation inside the store, but the fight tumbled outside and became increasingly violent: the men can be seen grabbing both of the women, slapping them in their heads and pulling their hair.
When the fight outside slowed down, Aisha Regan entered the store and began knocking over shelves. The men and her sister followed her inside, and the fight continued as they grappled, with Mr. Singh grabbing the women out by their braids.
The men’s reactions were “completely inappropriate,” Mr. Hollis said, and he believes they should have called the police if they thought the women needed to be removed from the store.
The incident was covered by local media and resulted in calls for unity and justice from city leaders. “Viewing the video of two Black women from our community being assaulted made me sick,” Mayor Bill Peduto tweeted last year. “We cannot be a civilized society and tolerate any violence against women. We must come together as one unified community and end all violence against women. All of us.”
Protests outside the gas station also followed, as demonstrators urged people to boycott the location.
Amber Sloan, who helped organize some of the protests, said she felt like the justice system failed the Regan sisters. “Somebody wasn’t fighting for them. These young girls were cheated out of justice.”
Ms. Sloan also noted that she faced the same charge of summary harassment after police accused her of making a threat against Mr. Hill on her Facebook page, and said her behavior was less serious than what the men did at the gas station. Her charge was later reduced to disorderly conduct.
Mr. Hill and the Regan sisters testified on Monday before Allegheny Common Pleas Judge Kevin G. Sasinoski in a non-jury trial. A charge of conspiracy against the gas station workers was also dropped.
Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter: @MickStinelli






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.