The mother of a man fatally shot by a Wilkinsburg police officer last year filed a federal lawsuit on Thursday alleging borough officials violated the man’s rights and used excessive force.
The lawsuit, filed in U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania by LaTasha Talley, names the borough of Wilkinsburg, police Chief Ophelia Coleman, Mayor Marita Garrett and Officer Robert Gowans as defendants. Officer Gowans’ partner, who is identified only as “Jane Doe,” is also listed as a defendant.
Officer Gowans killed Romir Talley, 24, on Dec. 22 during a early-morning foot chase following a report of a man pulling a silver handgun on another man at 1 a.m. near the intersection of Penn Avenue and Wood Street in Wilkinsburg.
According to a statement from the Allegheny County Police Department, who investigated the shooting, Officer Gowans and his partner were dispatched to the area of the incident and saw Mr. Talley, who appeared to match the suspect description.
When they exited a marked police vehicle and told him to take his hands out of his pockets, the man fled. The officers gave chase into an alley called Stoner Way.
As they ran after Mr. Talley in the dark, Mr. Talley fired one round at Officer Gowans, county police said. The officer returned fire and struck Mr. Talley seven times.
A silver revolver was recovered at the scene “with one spent cartridge recovered from inside the cylinder below the hammer,” county police said.
The Talley family and their attorney, Paul Jubas, have been skeptical of the narrative provided by police, alleging there was a case of mistaken identity and Mr. Talley was not the suspect and that he was wearing a black jacket, not the gray hoodie described by the caller, who was live with 911 dispatchers as police responded to the scene. Mr. Talley also had no prior criminal history.
“The circumstances by which this shooting occurred have been shrouded in mystery, as the Wilkinsburg Police Department does not utilize dash cams or body cams,” Mr. Jubas wrote in a statement. “Without the accountability of modern police tools, and without a transparent District Attorney’s Office, a piecemeal investigation was conducted by our offices. Numerous pieces of evidence have emerged, which contradict critical portions of the story told by Officer Robert Gowans.”
Mr. Jubas last month claimed EMS notes from the night of Mr. Talley’s death contradicted the official police narrative and boosted his own claim of mistaken identity, noting the caller told 911 operators that the police “pulled down into an alleyway and should’ve kept going on Penn” and the “male is still on Penn.”
The attorney also said he had begun his own investigation, and a witness claimed to have seen only seven shots being fired from a single gun, which made Mr. Jubas believe Mr. Talley may have never fired at all.
County Police Superintendent Coleman McDonough has said he stands by the original outline of events, and said the EMS notes Mr. Jubas referenced were “not as comprehensive” as the police dispatch records, “nor does Mr. Jubas apparently have access to all the recorded 911 calls or other investigative materials.”
The lawsuit filed Thursday lays out six charges, alleging Officer Gowans and his partner violated Mr. Talley’s constitutional rights. It also charges Officer Gowans with excessive force and battery.
“Even though Decedent did not match the description given by the 911 caller, the Defendant Officers conducted a hostile maneuver with their vehicle by pulling their marked car in front of Decedent, exiting their vehicle, and commanding that decedent “take his hands out of his pockets,” the lawsuit reads.
The suit also claims Ms. Garrett, the borough mayor, and Chief Coleman were liable for the death due to insufficient training given to the police officers, and states the failure to implement body cameras “constitutes a pattern and practice of deliberate indifference to the constitutional rights of all individuals in Wilkinsburg,” including Mr. Talley.
Chief Coleman said she was not aware of the lawsuit. “I have not made any statements, and I will not be making any statements until the investigation is over,” she said. Mayor Garrett did not respond to request for comment.
The county police turned over their findings to the District Attorney’s office for review, which is still ongoing.
At a news conference Thursday afternoon, Mr. Jubas declined to say whether he would accept the results of the DA’s investigation.
“I think that’s assuming a lot — that the DA will complete his investigation,” Mr. Jubas said. He pointed to the case of Marcus White, the 1-year-old known as “Baby Marcus” who was killed at a cookout in the East Hills neighborhood on May 21, 2013. Gregory Parker, 22, was charged this June with the baby’s killing, two years after he confessed.
“If we had a body cam and a dash cam, we would believe everything that they say, because we could prove it,” Mr. Jubas said. “Without that, we’re not going to, because we’ve been burned too many times.”
Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter: @MickStinelli.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.