Charges have been withdrawn for one of two Allegheny County plumbing inspectors charged last month with falsifying records.

Timothy Chelosky, 53, of McKeesport, remains suspended without pay pending the results of an internal county investigation. However, at a preliminary hearing in front of District Judge Richard G. Opiela on Sept. 23, four felony counts of tampering with public records were withdrawn.

District attorney spokesman Mike Manko said the charges were withdrawn pending further investigation, and turned over other questions to the county police.

In response to questions about the case, Allegheny County Police Investigative Division Commander Michael Peairs wrote: “The investigation is ongoing. Unfortunately we have no updates that we can provide at this time.”

Advertise with us

“We had a complete and full hearing, basically a trial,” James Wymard, Mr. Chelosky’s attorney, said. “It was pretty obvious that [the prosecutors] didn’t have sufficient evidence.”

Mr. Chelosky was alleged to have submitted inspection certification reports for dates and times at properties “he wouldn’t have been capable of completing due to his being at the properties so briefly as to be impossible to have completed the work he reported,” county police said last month.

According to a criminal complaint, investigations began after plumbing program manager Ivo Miller noticed inspections were being done outside inspectors’ assigned areas and beyond normal work hours.

Residents told detectives that the dates and times written on inspection certification reports by Mr. Chelosky and another inspector, Michael Kevin O’Toole, were inaccurate, and they did not have inspections completed at those times.

Detectives also monitored a residence and did not see Mr. Chelosky appear when he was supposed to be working on location, the complaint reads.

Advertise with us

But his attorney said prosecutors were not able to produce enough evidence to prove those allegations. Mr. Chelosky filed a grievance with his union following his suspension, and Mr. Wymard said he is confident the county’s investigation will clear him of any wrongdoing.

Mr. O’Toole, of Pittsburgh, still faces 11 felony charges and has a preliminary hearing set for Oct. 23. His attorney did not respond to requests for comment.

Matt Mertz Plumbing, which investigators said requested “the overwhelming majority” of the suspect inspections, was searched by county police on Sept. 10. No charges have been filed against the company or its employees.

John Linkosky, the attorney representing Matt Mertz Plumbing, said he hasn’t heard from county police since the warrant was served.

Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter: @MickStinelli