The 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals sent a sexual misconduct case against a Butler County judge back to U.S. District Court, saying the lower court incorrectly denied him qualified immunity.
The Court of Appeals affirmed most of the lower court’s order, which rejected Judge Thomas Doerr’s qualified immunity defense in the civil suit.
But the appellate court disagreed when the District Court denied Judge Doerr, the president judge of the Butler County Court of Common Pleas, qualified immunity on the plaintiff’s claim that his alleged harassment violated her First Amendment rights.
Judge Doerr is entitled to qualified immunity in that claim because neither the plaintiff nor the District Court’s ruling “alleges a violation of a clearly established right,” the opinion states. The Court of Appeals reversed the decision and remanded it to the lower court.
The plaintiff argued Judge Doerr violated her First Amendment association rights by coercing her to maintain their sexual relationship even after it had ended. She alleged he insisted she appear in her court so he could “look her over,” that he transferred her to a different division so she could “be close to him” and that he scolded her when she spoke to other men at work.
She also noted that Judge Doerr ran into her and her then-boyfriend at a Lowe’s store and said he hoped they were off the clock.
The plaintiff argued that she and her husband “were subjected to harassment at the hands of the Court’s administration under the direction or acquiescence of Doerr,” eventually causing her husband to retire, court documents state. The court noted that the plaintiff and her husband married despite the harassment.
“Neither the Supreme Court nor this Court has held that unmarried, romantic partners have a fundamental right to intimate association,” Judge Thomas Hardiman wrote in the opinion.
The appellate court also took issue with the cases cited by the lower court to support its denial of the judge’s qualified immunity.
One such case involved a subject of a police investigation who complained that an officer lied to the subject’s wife, costing him his marriage. “A police officer’s dishonesty is not sufficiently similar to harassment in the workplace,” the opinion states.
Another involved a case “where a wife was allegedly terminated from her position as superintendent of a correctional facility because of her marriage to a training officer at the same facility.”
“This is not enough to constitute a robust consensus of caselaw to put any reasonable official on notice that harassment violates an employee’s association rights,” Judge Hardiman wrote.
But even if that right had been established, the argument would not be applicable in this case since the remark Judge Doerr made to the plaintiff at Lowe’s “is insufficient to establish direct and substantial interference with her right to establish or maintain that relationship.”
Despite reversing that decision, the Court of Appeals upheld most of the lower court’s orders denying Judge Doerr qualified immunity.
Lawyers for Judge Doerr and the plaintiff did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
The plaintiff originally sued Judge Doerr after alleging multiple instances of misconduct and harassment. She said he invited her to his chambers multiple times after they met at a Christmas party.
After multiple refusals, she said they had intercourse in the judge’s chambers, court documents state. She claimed the judge’s advances were unwelcomed, and he told her that their sexual interactions were a “business relationship,” with the understanding that the relationship would lead to her getting her desired job as a probation officer.
When she became a probation officer in 2005, she alleges that Judge Doerr began summoning her to his chambers, persuading her to have sex, sharing pornography with her and discussing sex on the telephone, behavior that continued for four years.
When they ceased sexual relations in 2009, Judge Doerr continued his advances, asking her to film herself performing sexual acts, flirting with her from the bench, holding her “hand while explaining that he could help her return to her previous job” and interrupting her when he saw her speaking to male staff, according to the lawsuit.
After briefly leaving the probation office, she returned and was denied opportunities that her male counterparts had, such as her own office, overtime and training opportunities, she said.
When she told supervisors she planned to file a complaint with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, Judge Doerr placed her on a “performance improvement plan” despite that she had received a good performance review two months prior.
Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter: @MickStinelli.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.