The Pennsylvania Judicial Conduct Board on Wednesday filed formal charges against Allegheny County Common Pleas judge Mark V. Tranquilli, and recommended he be suspended.
The board wrote that Judge Tranquilli, who allegedly referred to a Black juror as “Aunt Jemima” while speaking in chambers to attorneys after a case ended in January, both violated the Judicial Code of Conduct and the Pennsylvania Constitution following allegations of misconduct, including using a racist epithet and Ebonics in the courtroom.
The alleged statements show Judge Tranquilli “performed his judicial duties with improper bias or prejudice” and “failed to promote public confidence in the judiciary and avoid impropriety,” the board wrote. Some of the judge’s conduct constitutes “racial and other harassment.”
The allegations “undermine both public confidence in the judiciary and its reputation,” the board wrote in the petition to the state’s Court of Judicial Discipline. “If Judge Tranquilli is permitted to continue exercising judicial duties during the pendency of the Board Complaint the public’s confidence in the judiciary will continue to erode.”
The board will present the findings to the Court of Judicial Discipline, where it may go to public trial and the board will have to substantiate the charges with clear evidence.
After reviewing the evidence, if the court finds the charges convincing, the judge could face sanctions ranging from reprimand to suspension or removal.
Read More
Read the Judicial Conduct Board’s formal charges:
Judge Tranquilli’s attorneys said he was not available for comment. They also declined to comment on the matter.
The board laid out six charges against Judge Tranquilli, who was elected to the court in 2013, regarding his conduct during four cases.
In the January incident, the retrial of a drug case, Judge Tranquilli is alleged to have added that the prosecutor knew “darn well” that when the juror “goes home to her baby daddy, he’s probably slinging heroin, too.”
Judge Tranquilli was “visibly affected” while reading the jury’s “not guilty” verdict on one of the charges in the case, the complaint reads. After sentencing the defendant, who was convicted on another charge, he convened with the attorneys and “immediately expressed bewilderment about the persons picked by them for jury service” in the case.
He questioned the prosecutor, Assistant District Attorney Ted Dutkowski, what he was thinking “putting that knucklehead Juror No. 11 on the jury?”
He then asked about Juror No. 12, the mother of a public defender, and he said according to the complaint “something to the effect of ‘Don’t you know she’s going to go to Sunday dinner with her daughter who will tell her all about the people being wrongly charged and having their rights violated?’”
Referring to Juror No. 4, a Black woman who was wearing a hair wrap, he said, “You weren’t out of strikes when you decided to put Aunt Jemima on the jury,” the complaint alleges, stating that her facial expressions and physical demeanor displayed a negative attitude towards the prosecutor's case.
These allegations drew criticism after press coverage in February, and the judge was restricted to administrative duties. Asked whether Judge Tranquilli’s is still at the court in that capacity, district court administrator Chris Connors said he couldn’t comment on a pending matter.
In addition to charges of bias, harassment and failure to promote public confidence in the courts, the judge also “failed to conduct himself in a patient, dignified and courteous manner.”
The alleged actions violated the state’s constitution by going against the Supreme Court’s judicial canon and code of ethics, and by “engaging in conduct that was so extreme it brought the judicial office itself into disrepute,” the complaint reads.
The 18-page complaint also references other instances of alleged misconduct, including that Judge Tranquilli lectured a woman who pleaded guilty to drug charges about having two children out of wedlock.
“So now, you have laid down twice with dogs, but you have woken up with two lovely children, probably two lovely children I’m betting you were probably not planning on,” the complaint quotes him as saying in October 2018. “And for the cost of three shiny quarters in any bathroom in any rest stop in Pennsylvania, you probably could have gone a different direction.”
He also said, “I’m going to tell you what I tell every person I put on probation,” and gave a speech about his “low tolerance for misbehavior.”
“I was a district attorney for 20 years, and for the last 13 years, all I did was dead body cases, dead body, dead body, dead body,” he said, according to the court transcript. “For the last eight years, I ran the homicide unit. If I had a nickel for every picture of a dead person I looked at on my desk while I was eating a turkey sandwich, I could retire right now and be a rich man. As a result of these experiences, there is no milk of human kindness left in these veins. It is just too much death.”
In another case, he told a defendant he would cast him “down amongst the [S]odomites” in state prison if the defendant violated probation, the complaint reads.
While discussing issues of communication to a Black couple during a custody conciliation, he told them, “[W]hen I say communication, I don’t mean, ‘and den da bitch done dis, and den da bitch done dat,” the complaint says.
The allegations have led to statements from the Abolitionist Law Center and several other advocacy groups asking for his resignation, as well as calls from NAACP leaders that he be disbarred.
Lisette McCormick, executive director of the Pennsylvania Interbranch Commission for Gender, Racial and Ethnic Fairness, said if the judge thought a juror would be biased because she is Black, it would corrupt the system of selecting a fair jury of one’s peers.
“That the jury would somehow not give a rational decision and result in acquittal is the height of bias and discrimination,” Ms. McCormick said.
Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com; 412-263-1869; and on Twitter: @MickStinelli






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.