A longtime Allegheny County prosecutor is stable in a local intensive care unit, another has been moved to a regular hospital room, and a third has passed the coronavirus on to his wife — and now fears for his newborn — as they continue treatment for COVID-19.

On Tuesday, the head of the union that represents the lawyers in the district attorney’s office and the public defender’s office said the courthouse should be closed — with all work occurring through videoconferencing — or at the least have temperature and symptom-checking stations at the entrances to ensure the safety of those who appear each day.

“They’re not protecting the employees and the public, generally, by following the [Centers for Disease Control and Prevention] recommendations,” said Kevin McCarthy, the bargaining unit president of their United Steelworkers local union.

He said he will be working with the county and court administration to try to convince them to take additional action.

Advertise with us

Mr. McCarthy, along with other members of the DA’s office and private criminal defense attorneys, have been outspoken on the issue since June 25 when word got out that an employee in the courthouse tested positive for the virus.

Since then, a total of five people who work in that Grant Street building have tested positive, as well as seven others across Allegheny County’s court system.

It is against that backdrop — as well as rising numbers of infections locally — that the judges in Allegheny County are also grappling with the notion that they might be forced by the state Supreme Court to resume criminal jury trials in September.

During a meeting with the criminal litigation section of the Allegheny County Bar Association on Wednesday, both President Judge Kim Berkeley Clark and criminal division Administrative Judge Jill Rangos said they spoke with Justice Max Baer, who told them the appellate court wanted jury trials to restart then.

In the bar meeting, Judge Clark said they could shoot for that date, but that because of the pandemic, there were several concerns, including getting enough jurors to appear, and having jurors who will be fair and not simply rushing to a verdict to get home.

Advertise with us

“I get it, the Supreme Court can tell me what I have to do,” she said. “If it is not safe to convene a jury, we’re not going to convene a jury.”

Stacey Witalec, a spokeswoman for the state Supreme Court said Tuesday there has been no such directive from the higher court, and instead, local president judges have the authority to resume operations on the time frame they see fit.

Court administrator Chris Connors said Tuesday that the Allegheny County emergency court expires Aug. 31.

“There are many long-incarcerated defendants awaiting trial and many victims of serious offenses waiting for their cases to be resolved,” he said in a statement. “That said, no decision has been made about when to resume jury trials, no juror summons have been sent, and the situation will be reviewed on a week-to-week basis, considering the most recent coronavirus data in Allegheny County.”

Defense attorney Thomas N. Farrell, who heads the bar’s criminal section, said there is no way jury trials should be occurring in the current climate. Mr. McCarthy agreed.

Advertise with us

“We can’t get jurors to come in in this environment,” Mr. McCarthy said. “We have a trajectory of infection going up.

“It’s just, as a practical matter, not going to happen.”

From the DA’s office, assistant district attorneys Russ Broman and Ted Dutkowski were both hospitalized because of the virus last week, while Assistant District Attorney Greg Stein began experiencing symptoms beginning the evening of July 3.

Mr. Broman has said he filed a complaint with the Occupational Safety and Health Administration over how the notification process for COVID-19 cases in the courthouse was handled.

Neither the district attorney’s office nor court administration have seen the complaint, they said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Broman has pneumonia, Mr. McCarthy said, but is stable and receiving oxygen in the intensive care unit.

Mr. Dutkowski is still isolated but was moved out of ICU to a regular hospital room on Monday and is much better than he was before. He is being weaned off of oxygen and said he was very close to having to be placed on a ventilator. Among his treatments, he received convalescent blood plasma, antiviral drugs and steroids.

Mr. Dutkowski is believed to have contracted the virus in Judge Susan Evashavik DiLucente’s courtroom the day after the positive employee was working there, Mr. McCarthy said.

Mr. Dutkowski and Mr. Broman share office space, and their desks are just a few feet apart. Mr. Stein is believed to have contracted the virus from Mr. Broman, whom he sat next to in a courtroom for about 30 minutes a few days after that, Mr. McCarthy said.

Mr. Stein, 33, did not have to be hospitalized for his symptoms but experienced fever, headache, body aches and upper respiratory symptoms, Mr. McCarthy said.

Advertise with us

Although Mr. Stein has mostly recovered, his wife has now tested positive, and he is fearful for his 9-week-old daughter, he continued.

All of the additional positive tests, Mr. McCarthy said, would have been avoided if the courthouse had been shut down immediately upon notification that an employee was sick.

“That is a sentiment widely held by the DAs, PDs, and the defense bar,” Mr. McCarthy said.

After the positive test results became public, and employees and attorneys raised the alarms, Judge Clark sent an email to court staff informing everyone that there would be a renewed push to conduct as much business as possible through videoconferencing.

Right now, Mr. McCarthy said, on an average day, there are fewer than 20 attorneys in the DA’s office, and around 15 to 20 staff members. Typically, the office has about 110 people working in the courthouse, he said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Connors said the court system has asked about 60 employees to work from home out of an abundance of caution relative to possible exposure.

So far, he said, none of them have tested positive.

In the meantime, Judge Clark has also been working to reinforce an order requiring masks in the building and in every courtroom.

Mr. McCarthy said the union has argued that the tracking and tracing of people who may have been exposed has to be more aggressive.

In the case of Mr. Stein, he notified First Assistant Deputy District Attorney Rebecca Spangler that he was experiencing COVID-19 symptoms on the morning of July 4, Mr. McCarthy said. Mr. Stein, 33, told Ms. Spangler he was waiving any confidentiality because he wanted to make sure any of his colleagues who might have been exposed were aware, so they, too, could be tested.

Advertise with us

Mr. McCarthy said Ms. Spangler did not notify the rest of the staff until 4:30 p.m. Monday.

Mike Manko, a spokesman with the DA’s office, said Mr. Stein’s test results confirming that he was positive weren’t returned until Monday afternoon, and that Ms. Spangler sent the message within a couple of hours.

On the issue of temperature checks, Mr. McCarthy said it is one of the measures being used at a lot of facilities, including doctors’ offices and universities, to try to stop the spread of the virus.

But he has been told by court administrators that it’s the county’s building, and that the county controls entrances and exits.

“They just keep pointing fingers at each other,” he said.

Advertise with us

Amie Downs, the county spokeswoman, said Allegheny County officials and the courts have spoken about temperature checks and other measures.

“We will continue to have those conversations to determine what is most appropriate based on advice from the Health Department, as well as feasible for a facility such as this while remaining consistent with all offices and facilities,” she said. “We do know that the courts are looking at specific options for their floors as well.”

Mr. Farrell said it is the county’s responsibility.

“The county executive controls where we can eat, how much alcohol we can drink, where we can drink it, but he can’t take care of his own buildings,” Mr. Farrell said. “They’re not taking care of their own employees.”

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.