A second suspect has been arrested in connection with the shooting death of a 19-year-old New Castle man who went missing earlier this month.

New Castle police said Todd Henry, 47, was taken into custody Monday night.

Mr. Henry and his son Connor Henry, 20, both of New Castle, have been charged in the death of Amari Wise in their garage in the 900 block of Adams Street, according to police. Mr. Wise’s family reported him missing June 5.

Amari Wise (New Castle Police Department)

Connor Henry, 20, was taken into custody Sunday in Ocean City, Md., during a traffic stop after authorities learned he was staying in the area. He is charged with firing the gun that police say killed Mr. Wise. New Castle police are awaiting his extradition from Maryland.

Advertise with us

Police said the shooting took place late June 5. Several people were hanging out in the Henrys’ garage, smoking marijuana and drinking, when Mr. Wise showed up, according to a criminal complaint.

After about 15 minutes, Mr. Wise got into an argument with someone. He stood over the unidentified man, who was sitting on a couch, and threatened to shoot him, the complaint said.

Mr. Wise put his hand on a fanny pack slung across his chest, one witness said. The other witness said a gun was partly out of the fanny pack when Connor Henry shot Mr. Wise once from behind, according to the complaint.

Detectives did not indicate what the argument was about.

Investigators said Todd Henry scrubbed down the garage to hide the evidence, moved Mr. Wise’s body and hid the car the victim was driving.

Advertise with us

New Castle police Chief Bobby Salem told KDKA-TV, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s news partner, that Mr. Wise’s remains were found Monday. No further details were available.

Connor Henry is charged with homicide and tampering with evidence; police accused him of hiding the murder weapon. Todd Henry is charged with conspiracy, obstruction of justice and tampering with evidence.