A family-owned North Hills construction firm whose former controller admitted to stealing some $8.7 million is blaming Citizens Bank for not catching the thefts or informing the owner about suspicious activity dating back years before the culprit was arrested.

Marco Contractors of Marshall last week sued the bank in federal court on negligence and breach of contract claims.

The suit concerns the activities of Sue O'Neill, who became a federal felon in November when she pleaded guilty to wire fraud and a tax offense in connection with her decade-long embezzlement scheme.

The complaint, filed on behalf of Marco owner Martin Smith and his son Nicholas Smith, is seeking "consequential and punitive damages" from the bank where the company held its various accounts because of what the suit describes as "grossly negligent, sufficiently wanton, willful and reckless action and inaction" in regard to managing those accounts.

Advertise with us

Citizens did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Ms. O'Neill's systematic thefts date back to 2009.

The suit says that bank officers Rod Vingle, James Nealon and Frank Livorio never told Martin Smith about suspicions of fraud or discussed ways to prevent it despite meetings and annual reviews with him. The suit says internal emails uncovered in the criminal investigation revealed that the bank had concerns about fraud as early as 2014 but never told Mr. Smith or anyone else at Marco. The bank dealt only with Ms. O'Neill, according to the suit.

As a consequence, the suit says, Citizens ended up providing the embezzler with "the roadmap to successfully steal millions of dollars from Marco."

Ms. O'Neill waived indictment in November before a U.S. judge and admitted to one of the largest embezzlements ever uncovered in this district. She is awaiting sentencing.

Advertise with us

She and her partner, identified only as R.G., used the money to buy property, cars and construction equipment for their own company, Bulldog Contractors. R.G. has not been identified or charged but corporate ownership records show that Bulldog is owned by Robin L. Gabel.

Ms. O'Neill issued payroll checks drawn on the Marco account at Citizens and had them deposited into Bulldog's account. She made checks payable to Bulldog from Rockerz Inc., a subsidiary of Marco, and deposited those in Bulldog's account and also made checks payable to Bulldog from Marco. In addition, she wired millions in funds directly from Marco to Bulldog.

To conceal her theft, she doctored the accounts payable records at Marco to falsely show the money she stole had been paid to legitimate Marco vendors.

Ms. O'Neill also didn't pay income tax on the stolen money through the years.

As part of the case, the U.S. attorney's office has moved to forfeit numerous assets as having been bought with stolen money, including properties in Economy, Ohio Township, Butler and Alexandria, Ky.

Prosecutors are also seeking $254,000 in proceeds from the sale of property, dozens of cars and construction vehicles, jewelry, a Steelers season ticket seat license and pinball machines.