This story was updated at 11:30 a.m. on Sept. 11, 2020.

A judge on Thursday sent the former controller of a Marsahall construction firm to federal prison for more than five years for stealing some $8.7 million from the family-owned company that entrusted her for years to handle the books.

U.S. District Judge Donetta Ambrose imposed a term of 64 months on Sue O'Neill, 55, of Leetsdale, who had admitted that she embezzled the money from Marco Contractors over many years and didn't pay income taxes on it.

She pleaded guilty to wire fraud and a count of filing a false return for 2018, acknowledging her conduct in six other tax counts for which she could be punished at sentencing.

Advertise with us

O'Neill's thefts from Marco and a related company represented one of the largest embezzlement cases ever prosecuted in western Pennsylvania.

O'Neill used $6.7 million of the stolen money to support a new business venture, Bulldog Contractors, and kept the other $2 million for herself.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Lee Karl said she pilfered the money from Marco starting in 2009 and concealed the income from the thefts on her taxes beginning in tax year 2013.

According to court records and her plea, she and a partner, identified only as R.G., used the stolen money to buy property, high-end cars and construction equipment for Bulldog Contractors, created in 2014.

R.G. has not been charged or further identified, but online records indicate that Bulldog is owned by Robin L. Gabel.

Advertise with us

Mr. Karl said Ms. O'Neill and R.G. spent the stolen money in various ways, including buying two 1969 Ford GT 500 cars, each worth about $165,000, and renovating a 1969 Ford Mustang for $163,000. Those vehicles along with real estate, bank accounts, tractors and other assets will all be forfeited to the federal government as part of O'Neill's plea agreement.

In addition, she will be responsible for restitution to Marco in the amount of $8.5 million, plus $215,000 to a Marco-controlled company called Rockerz Inc. and another $428,000 to the IRS.

In asking for non-custodial sentence O'Neill's lawyer, Martin Dietz, said his client is "humbled and ashamed of her actions" but shouldn't go to jail.

Many of her family members and friends wrote letters on her behalf, including her husband, who recounted her struggles after the death of one of their sons and her attempted suicide after the discovery of her thefts from Marco.

Others described her as a loving mother, wife, aunt and friend.

Advertise with us

Mr. Dietz also noted that O'Neill did not personally benefit from any money deposited into the Bulldog bank accounts and said she has voluntarily returned items she bought with stolen money, including Steelers season tickets and jewelry. In addition, he said, she has given the government documents relating to Bulldog and provided information about her former partner, R.G.

Mr. Karl asked for prison time for O'Neill, saying she accumulated "this staggering figure" - $8.7 million - by manipulating Marco's payroll system, writing checks to herself and writing checks and wiring money to Bulldog.

"All the while, she lied to, while working closely with, the people from who she stole," Mr. Karl wrote in sentencing papers. "The betrayal was unimaginable to the victims, and to this day they struggle to understand her actions."

Mr. Karl said O'Neill did not grow up in dire circumstances or use the stolen money to support a family. Instead, he said, "there is only one word that is needed to describe her motive – greed."

She spent tens of thousands of dollars on jewelry; tens of thousands on a country club membership, $11,000 on Kiss concert tickets and memorabilia; $160,285 on a Ford Shelby; $164,835 on another Ford Shelby; $163,565 to renovate a Ford Mustang; and $134,175 on a single family residence at Zassick Drive, which she transferred to R.G. for $1.

Advertise with us

Over the years starting in 2009, O'Neill issued payroll checks drawn on the Marco account at Citizens Bank and had them deposited directly into Bulldog's account at Key Bank, according to a criminal complaint.

The total amount in that scheme was $2 million. O'Neill manipulated Marco's payroll system to conceal the fraud.

She also made checks payable to Bulldog from Rockerz Inc. and deposited those in the Key Bank account. The total stolen in that way was $215,000.

She also made checks payable to Bulldog from Marco totalling another $1 million and wired funds from Marco to the Bulldog account totaling $5.5 million.

To hide what she was doing, she manipulated the accounts payable records at Marco to fraudulently reflect that the money she stole had been paid to legitimate Marco vendors.

In addition to the prison term, Judge Ambrose ordered that O'Neill be on probation for two years when she is released.