A South Park man decimated his church’s finances by funneling over $1 million into his family’s pockets in a yearslong scheme. By the time officials discovered the theft in 2018, just 58 cents remained in one church account, which once held at least $100,000.

On Tuesday, David E. Reiter faced the consequences.

Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey A. Manning sentenced Reiter, the former administrator of Westminster Presbyterian Church in Upper St. Clair, to 10 to 20 years in state prison.

The judge said that although Reiter had shown remorse, “the court is not in the forgiveness business.”

Advertise with us

Reiter, 50, remained expressionless as he exited the courtroom in handcuffs.

The judge also signed a restitution order, meaning that Reiter is responsible for repaying the $1.2 million he stole from the church. Payback seems unlikely.

Reiter said during the sentencing hearing that he would need to work multiple jobs in order to pay restitution, something impossible from behind bars.

Judge Manning said that even though a sentence should ideally give back victims what they have lost, in this case it just “doesn’t seem to be in the cards.”

Church pastors, however, remained positive.

Advertise with us

The Rev. Bruce Lancaster, the church’s interim senior pastor, said community members have been “very generous,” and that donations have enabled the church to continue its mission activities in Pittsburgh and throughout the world.

Rev. Lancaster said that although the church’s budget was impacted by Reiter’s crimes, “it has not kept us down.”

After 17 years as a church administrator, Mr. Reiter’s fraudulent behavior came to light when the treasurer of the church board of directors checked an audit.

The treasurer contacted the Rev. James Gilchrist about the audit, and told him that Reiter had repeatedly made excuses as to why the auditor couldn’t meet in person.

Investigators later found that although the treasurer believed he had spoken with the man who had conducted the audit over the phone, Reiter had given the treasurer the number of a prepaid cell phone — purchased with church funds — and pretended to be the auditor.

Advertise with us

On Nov. 27, 2018, Rev. Gilchrist sat down with Reiter to discuss the treasurer’s concerns. In that conversation, detailed in a criminal complaint, Reiter told Rev. Gilchrist that he “needed to resign” from his position because he had done some “bad things.”

These “bad things” turned out to be stealing more than $900,000 from the church bank account, $100,000 from early childhood education programs, and more than $200,000 by using the church credit card, according to investigators.

Reiter told Rev. Gilchrist he had stolen the money in order to “make things better at home,” according to the complaint.

As church administrator, Reiter was responsible for payroll, transferring money between accounts and paying vendors, among other financial obligations.

Upon examining payroll reports, bank statements and other documents, Rev. Gilchrist found that Reiter had transferred most of the church’s reserve bank account, child care and nursery school bank accounts to the church’s operating account.

Advertise with us

From there, Reiter had deposited money into a joint account shared by him and his wife, Connie Jo Reiter, according to the complaint.

Ms. Reiter, 45, has been charged with receiving stolen property and conspiracy. Jury selection in her trial before Judge Manning is scheduled for Jan. 22.

Each month, Reiter received a deposit in the joint account marked “payroll Westminster Pres,” which far exceeded the authorized payroll, according to the complaint. Two debit cards issued on the account, one for Reiter and one for his wife, as well as check deposits with memo lines such as “medical expense reimbursements” also helped cover Reiter’s expenses, the complaint said.

Other expenses incurred by Reiter included trips to Disney World, Cedar Point, Hershey Park, Kings Island and camping excursions, the complaint said. Reiter also used the funds for his children’s music lessons, Pittsburgh Pirates tickets, restaurants, utility bills, groceries, vehicle repairs and other personal expenses.

The early childhood education programs account was most severely impacted, with less than a dollar remaining when church officials discovered the fraud.

Advertise with us

In October, Reiter pleaded guilty to 10 charges, including stolen property, theft, forgery, access device fraud, tampering with records and unlawful use of a computer. He also pleaded no contest to conspiring with his wife.

Judge Manning sentenced Reiter to one to two years on each count to be served consecutively.

The Rev. Louise Rogers, an associate pastor, said that a loan was extended within the church in order to ensure the education programs could keep running despite a drained bank account.

Rev. Rogers said that the program — a “very important ministry” within the church — is now “flourishing.”

If Ms. Reiter is convicted, she and her husband would be jointly responsible for paying the restitution, according to Assistant District Attorney Jon Pittman.

Abigail Mihaly: amihaly@post-gazette.com