For the last 20 years, District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. has not had to campaign for Allegheny County’s top prosecutor position.
This election season, he’s had to do it twice.
In the May primary, he easily dispatched former Chief Deputy Public Defender Turahn Jenkins with 59% of the vote, and got enough signatures as a Republican write-in to be listed on that side of the ticket, as well.
But he learned the next month that another longtime public defender was running against him as an independent in the general election.
Lisa Middleman came out strong, gathering three times as many signatures for her nominating petitions as were required. She has been out in the community at countless events — from house parties to candidate forums to community gatherings. And Ms. Middleman has kept pace with Mr. Zappala in fundraising, too, with both candidates showing about $200,000 raised through the Oct. 25 reporting period.
But experts say that defeating an entrenched Democratic incumbent can be an uphill battle. Even though progressives have won DA seats in Boston, Philadelphia and Arlington, Va., it’s not yet clear if Pittsburgh will be next.
Read More
The challenger
Ms. Middleman, with no experience as an elected official or politician, but 32 years defending indigent clients against the most serious charges, immediately set out with a progressive agenda.
She has earned endorsements from the likes of Democratic state Reps. Summer Lee, Sara Innamorato and Ed Gainey, as well as Pittsburgh City Councilwomen Erika Strassburger and Deb Gross; SEIU Healthcare Pennsylvania; One Pennsylvania; UNITE!; and Democracy for America.
During her career, Ms. Middleman, 57, of Franklin Park, has seen up-close what the criminal justice system can do to someone — or for someone.
Ms. Middleman represented a black man in a 2002 homicide case in which her client, along with another man, was accused of killing a white man during a botched robbery over the sale of marijuana.
She filed a pretrial motion asking that the jury pool to be summoned for the case be representative of the racial makeup of the county. The motion was denied, and her client went to trial in a courtroom with a white judge, a white prosecutor, a white defense attorney and an all-white jury panel.
The defendant testified that it was the co-defendant in the case who fired the fatal shot, and that he didn't even know there would be a robbery.
The jury didn't believe him, and he was convicted of second-degree murder and sent to prison for life without parole.
Ms. Middleman called it a system failure.
"Every single individual who goes to trial is entitled to a jury pool that represents a fair cross-section of the county," she said. "It's very difficult for anyone to have faith in a criminal justice system that doesn't look anything like them."
But in another case, one of Ms. Middleman’s toughest, she saw the system work.
She represented an 18-year-old who developed schizophrenia and attacked his younger half-brothers when they got home from school in 2007.
One of the boys died.
Ms. Middleman's client was arrested and committed to Mayview State Hospital in South Fayette, and for years, he was incompetent to stand trial.
But her client also cooperated with every step in his treatment, eventually being able to move from hospitalization to a community residential program and finally to his own apartment.
At a review hearing in 2017, the prosecution dismissed the case, though noting that the man must remain in treatment.
At the time, Ms. Middleman expressed her gratitude toward the system.
“The prosecution and the defense worked together toward a goal that took into account the humanity of all of the people involved,” she said. “The victims were considered. The witnesses were considered. The accused was considered. And most importantly, the safety of the community was considered.
“It was handled in a way that let everybody heal.”
Part of Ms. Middleman’s platform involves treating both mental illness and addiction as health issues to reduce jail population.
In addition, she wants to create a conviction integrity unit in the DA’s office, as well as an environmental justice unit.
Ms. Middleman has said she wants to examine racial disparity within the criminal justice system and would do that, at least in part, by reviewing data on charging and bail decisions, as well as plea offers and convictions to determine whether minorities are being treated equally.
She has also said she would reform civil asset forfeiture practices in the District Attorney’s office and advocate with legislators and other prosecutors to reform juvenile justice and to better investigate police officers involved in criminal activity.
The incumbent
Mr. Zappala, 62, of Fox Chapel prides himself on being able to bring diverse groups together to make change.
Since he’s been in office, he participated in the creation of the Criminal Justice Advisory Board, bringing together stakeholders in the system to address ongoing problems.
He has also worked with community elected officials, law enforcement and businesses to bring technological advancement in policing — such as the use of surveillance cameras along public roadways to provide evidence and license-plate reading cameras to help find suspects’ vehicles.
He also has worked with local school districts — including most recently Montour — to implement security upgrades to ensure a safe learning environment at the high school.
Mr. Zappala has created warrant offices, which allow police officers to get advice from prosecutors and approval of charges in their own communities, as well as helped to facilitate diversionary programs — like DUI court, mental health court, domestic violence court and others — to get necessary help to people charged with crimes.
Those courts, Mr. Zappala said — just after watching 22 people graduate from the Veterans’ Court program on Wednesday — are invaluable.
Without the program, he said, the participants would likely be incarcerated as repeat offenders. Instead, using the Veterans’ Court resources, they can now move forward.
“They protected us,” he said. “They deserve a chance.”
But Mr. Zappala said that during his career, he is most proud of creating two specialized units in the DA’s office, one focusing exclusively on child abuse and another on domestic violence.
It allows the prosecution to “treat people as people and not statistics or files,” he said.
Mr. Zappala said he believes in holding police officers accountable, both by prosecuting them if crimes are alleged, but also by having them wear body cameras while out in the community.
As far as reducing the jail population, an important topic among progressives, Mr. Zappala said his office has worked to do that by diverting about one-third of people with substance abuse disorders into treatment. But he acknowledges that there’s more work to be done.
He has endorsements from the Allegheny County Democratic Committee, as well as 47 neighborhood committees, the Steel City Stonewall Democrats and the AFL-CIO.
Throughout the campaign, Mr. Zappala has posted four podcasts on his website, ranging in topics from animal cruelty to the use of technology to fight help fight crime.
He also provides his stance on a variety of widely debated criminal justice issues, like bail reform, and brags about the work his office has done to support victims of domestic violence and elder abuse.
The campaign
During the election cycle, Mr. Zappala faced criticism for his decision not to debate Ms. Middleman at a local candidates’ forum. Prior to the primary in May, Mr. Zappala refused to debate Mr. Jenkins, as well, saying in an interview with the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette that he was “done with socialists and ACLU forums.”
At the same time, Mr. Zappala said he would be willing to engage in a debate in a “legitimate forum,” like one offered by the League of Women Voters.
But in September, when the league reached out to Mr. Zappala to hold a DA’s candidate forum, his campaign responded that he had a scheduling conflict. The league, which was working in conjunction with the American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania for the forum, offered to Mr. Zappala to pick a few other dates that could work with his calendar.
When pushed, Mr. Zappala’s campaign later issued a statement to the Post-Gazette saying he had “no desire to share a stage” with Ms. Middleman, citing comments she made in 1992 regarding jury selection, in which she said she didn’t want fat women on the panel. In a transcript of that proceeding, Ms. Middleman referred to them as "big, fat, fat piggy people.”
Ms. Middleman has said she regrets the words she used then and that they were intended to be tongue-in-cheek relative to a prosecutor’s allegation that she was racially biased during jury selection. She also suggested, in response to Mr. Zappala’s comment, that a candidate forum would be a good place to address any perceived shortcomings he saw in her.
The two never did meet to debate.
G. Terry Madonna, the director of the Center for Politics and Public Affairs at Franklin & Marshall College, said the surest way to beat an incumbent is to give the public a reason to want to throw that person out of office.
A DA’s race without such a thing, Mr. Madonna said, generally is low-profile, and potential voters pay little attention to it.
Although there was a rallying cry of sorts following the acquittal of former East Pittsburgh police Officer Michael Rosfeld, who is white, in the shooting death of 17-year-old Antwon Rose II, who was black, in March, the community push-back seems to have lessened.
It is clear, Mr. Madonna said, that progressives are gaining traction in urban areas across the United States, but he said, local elections for district attorney “tend to be dominated by ritualistic voters.”
“If she were to defeat him, it would be a huge upset.”
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.