The owner of a series of addiction clinics avoided federal prison on Wednesday on her conviction for illegal distribution of Suboxone and is right back where she started — overseeing patient treatment as the owner.

U.S. District Judge Arthur Schwab sentenced Jennifer Hess, 50, to probation, including 90 days of home confinement on electronic monitoring. She'll also have to perform 100 hours of community service, pay a $10,000 fine and pay restitution of $80,000 to Medicare and Medicaid and Gateway Health.

Hess, owner of Redirections Treatment Advocates, had pleaded guilty to aiding five contract doctors at her clinics in Washington County and West Virginia to dole out Suboxone for cash.

The doctors were all indicted along with Hess and Chris Handa, the office manager. No one has ended up in prison and two of the doctors, prosecuted in West Virginia instead of here, were acquitted.

Advertise with us

Everyone was charged with conspiring to issue prescriptions outside the scope of any real treatment.

Hess, of Washington, Pa., admitted that she filled out and sometimes signed doctors' names on blank prescriptions. RTA only accepted cash or credit cards, charging $175 for a first visit and $120 after that. The doctors conducted cursory exams of patients on the first visit and didn't offer any follow-ups after that, nor did RTA provide any counseling for addicts as required by law.

Two doctors, Michael Bummer and Madhu Aggarwal, pre-signed blank scripts in advance and gave them to Hess and Handa, who filled in the patient's name, date and the prescription. The doctors weren't in the office and never saw the patients but were paid based on the number of scripts they issued.

Hess and her lawyer, Martin Dietz, admitted that what she did was illegal but said she didn't deserve prison because they maintain she was acting with good faith to help as many patients as she could.

In delivering a long, tearful statement to the judge, Hess said that at one point she had 750 patients who were constantly contacting her by text at all hours for help.

Advertise with us

A psychologist by training, she portrayed herself as selflessly devoted to her patients at the expense of all else, eschewing vacations and personal time so she could aid their recovery.

"It was my life," she said, and she asked that the judge consider that, unlike many greed-motivated pill mill defendants prosecuted in federal court, "I had the best intentions."

She paid herself a salary, she said, but was not living extravagantly.

Several patients, all of whom requested anonymity, testified on her behalf, saying she was always available for them.

"I trust her and I know she cares," said one.

Advertise with us

An Army veteran, Hess said she most values God and country. Now, she said, she's a federal felon.

"Seeing the words 'United States v. Jennifer Hess' is the hardest thing I have ever experienced," she said, as she wept.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Bob Cessar, who leads a team that investigates and prosecutes bad doctors who are contributing to the opioid crisis, offered no argument before the judge, although in court papers he asked for a "robust" sentence to deter others. Under sentencing guidelines Hess faced a possible 27 to 33 months behind bars.

"RTA epitomized the model of profit over treatment," Mr. Cessar wrote. "The physicians fell into step with defendant Hess, and engaged in criminal conduct. This conduct, set out in the presentence report, was not just bad medicine; it was criminal medicine."

The judge agreed that Hess "knowingly" committed crimes and that she knew the doctors working for her weren't seeing any patients. He said she also ripped off insurance because those patients used Medicare and Medicaid or private insurance to pay for their Suboxone at pharmacies.

Advertise with us

But he said Hess was a hard worker with many supporters and no criminal history. Others charged in the case also received probationary sentences. He said probation was sufficient in her case, too.

The investigation of RTA first became public in January 2018 when agents raided the clinics as part of a Justice Department crackdown on pill mills.

To date, 25 doctors and medical professionals have been indicted in this district, the most of any U.S. attorney's office nationwide.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com