A Pennsylvania constable from Wilkins has been charged with intervening in a child custody dispute last year when authorities said he illegally helped a woman whisk her sons out of state and then charged her hundreds of dollars for his aid.

Anthony J. Cioppa Jr., who turns 48 Sunday, is charged with two felony counts each of interference with custody of children and concealment of the whereabouts of a child. He’s also charged with theft by deception, obstruction of the administration of law or other government function and official oppression.

An investigator with the Allegheny County District Attorney’s Office accused Mr. Cioppa of misconduct in the child custody case involving Cheyanna Stafford and her ex-husband. The case began in Utah around 2012 and continued in Pennsylvania, where Stafford sent her sons to live with their father, who was later incarcerated.

Mr. Cioppa turned himself in Friday and was being held at the Allegheny County Jail.

Advertise with us

Stafford, 32, of Monroeville, first encountered Mr. Cioppa in June 2018 after she obtained a temporary emergency custody order for her children from Common Pleas Judge Susan Evashavik DiLucente, according to a criminal complaint by Inspector Darrel Parker with the DA’s detectives. She was supposed to share custody with her ex-husband’s mother in Monroeville.

Stafford told an investigator that she could not afford to pay the county sheriff’s office to have the custody order served, and she was referred by someone to Mr. Cioppa.

Sheriff’s Chief Deputy Kevin Kraus said his office has no record of Stafford being there, and he noted that the sheriff’s office does not charge fees to serve custody or restraining orders.

On June 19, 2018, the complaint said, Mr. Cioppa agreed to serve the order for $150 before raising his rate to $450.

The next day, the complaint said, Mr. Cioppa went to the home of Stafford’s former mother-in-law “in an attempt to take custody of Stafford’s sons.” He produced a one-page document and said “this was a court order from Judge Evashavik DiLucente directing him to take custody of the juveniles,” according to the complaint.

Advertise with us

But someone at the house told Mr. Cioppa “that she had a valid court order from Judge Evashavik DiLucente awarding full custody to [the former mother-in-law] and all previous orders were void.”

During the discussion, the judge called Mr. Cioppa, the complaint said. Judge Evashavik DiLucente told the DA’s investigator that “she did call Cioppa and told him not to take the boys and to leave the residence,” according to the complaint.

On June 28, 2018, the complaint said, Mr. Cioppa texted Stafford: “It’s time for a snatching.”

She replied that “she did not want to scare her kids and didn’t know what to do,” the complaint said. “Cioppa advised her to buy three airplane tickets and get them safe home in Utah.”

The complaint indicates that on or around the next day, Stafford somehow got her children. Mr. Cioppa told her by text that she did not have to pay him then, that she should get three plane tickets “and get the hell out of Pa,” the complaint said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Cioppa drove Stafford and her children to a hotel near Pittsburgh International Airport, the complaint said. “Cioppa told the hotel clerk that Stafford and her sons were in ‘protective custody’ and no one was to know where they were. Cioppa told the clerk and Stafford that the ‘safe word’ for contact was ‘pineapple.’ Cioppa then went into the room and checked it for security,” according to the complaint.

Stafford told Mr. Cioppa on June 30, 2018, that she and her children had landed in Arizona. A day earlier, the complaint said, the children’s grandmother had obtained a court order granting her custody of the children. “Cioppa told Stafford to change her phone number,” the complaint said.

According to the complaint, on July 1, 2018, Mr. Cioppa told Stafford she owed him $1,310 “for his services.” She had already paid him $390, the complaint said.

“He texted her that his services for something as complicated usually require a retainer fee of $1,500,” the complaint said. “He told her that he also had to pay his partner $200 for five hours of work.”

Mr. Cioppa termed his work “constable services,” according to the complaint.

Advertise with us

When Stafford told Mr. Cioppa she was broke after paying for a hotel and airplane tickets, he threatened to charge her with theft, the complaint said. They bargained about payment, and Mr. Cioppa ultimately setlled on $300 as a “good faith” payment for his work as a “fixer,” the complaint said.

Stafford was charged in July 2018 with violating the court’s custody order and taking her children to Utah. She was arrested there, extradited to Allegheny County, and pleaded guilty in February to two counts of concealment of the whereabouts of a child. She was sentenced to 152 days in jail and 18 months probation.

President Judge Kim Berkeley Clark confirmed Friday that her office would handle requests by the DA’s office to have a constable license suspended or revoked.

The DA’s office said it cannot seek the removal of a constable until a conviction has been made.

“Our standard practice when a constable is charged is to ask that a condition of bond be that he or she not be permitted to perform any constable functions in Pennsylvania pending the outcome of the charges,” said Mike Manko, spokesman for the DA’s office.

Advertise with us

Judge Evashavik DiLucente declined comment, saying it’s a pending case.

Defense attorney Ryan Tutera said he has not yet been able to fully review the complaint against his client and could not comment.

"He's entitled to due process," Mr. Tutera said.

Mr. Cioppa faces additional charges of theft by deception and official oppression from April.

He is scheduled for trial on that case before Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Thomas E. Flaherty in January.

Advertise with us

In the earlier case, a woman said Mr. Cioppa agreed to provide investigative services for her in exchange for money in April.

According to the criminal complaint, he told the woman he worked for the Karen Myers Law Office, but when she contacted that law firm, she was told they had no relationship with Mr. Cioppa.

The woman, according to the complaint, contacted Mr. Cioppa, who said he would return her money, but he never did.

He is charged in that case with theft by deception and official oppression.

Mr. Cioppa was expected to be admitted into the county's Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition program on that case, Mr. Tutera said, but that could be in jeopardy now based on the new charges.

Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg. Staff writer Paula Reed Ward contributed.