A Georgia woman, her husband and her godmother on Monday sued Churchill borough and a police officer there in federal court, saying the officer violated the U.S. Constitution by arresting the woman after questioning her while she was out for a walk and taking pictures of trees with her phone.

Rebecca Suits, her husband David Burkett, and her godmother in Wilkinsburg, Lougwin Spencer, brought the 11-count claim against Officer Stephen Shaulis and his employer.

At a news conference Downtown announcing the lawsuit, the plaintiffs’ attorney, Todd Hollis, called for Officer Shaulis to be barred from police work.

Mr. Hollis was previously involved in litigation against Officer Shaulis who, as a school resource officer in the Woodland Hills School District, was accused of using excessive force when he knocked out a 14-year-old student’s tooth in an April 2017 incident. In 2015, Officer Shaulis was filmed shocking a student with a Taser.

Advertise with us

"I don't ever want to see Stephen Shaulis working as a police officer or in law enforcement ever again," Mr. Hollis said. "Money is not enough."

Despite the allegations against him at Woodland Hills, Officer Shaulis has not faced any consequences, Mr. Hollis said.

"He has not come before a single judge. He has not lost $1," he said. "It has to stop. This police officer has to go."

Reached by phone Monday afternoon, Officer Shaulis said, "There's a video of the incident. We'll let the video speak for itself."

He said he would not comment on whether he's discussed the incident or the lawsuit with his chief.

Advertise with us

A message to the chief had not yet been returned Monday afternoon.

The complaint says that Mrs. Suits, a stay-at-home mom, was visiting from Brunswick, Ga., to care for Mrs. Spencer after surgery when she decided to go for a walk on Sept. 23 in nearby Churchill. A person called 911 to report a suspicious woman walking around taking pictures and gave a description.

Officer Shaulis arrived and demanded her identification without legal cause, the lawsuit said.

Mrs. Suits — who appeared at the news conference with her husband, godmother, younger brother and a family friend — said in the suit that she was taking pictures because she enjoyed the scenery. She was walking on a public street when Officer Shaulis rolled up and asked if she lived in the neighborhood.

When Officer Shaulis first approached her about 7 p.m. she said she greeted him cordially.

Advertise with us

She told him she was staying with her godmother "just up the road" in Wilkinsburg. He asked her for her name and why she was there. She gave her name and said she was out for a stroll, according to the suit, but he kept demanding more information. She decided to end her walk and return to Wilkinsburg. The officer followed her in his car, she said.

Mrs. Suits said at the news conference that the officer told her that he’d received a call about squatters in the neighborhood.

"'Do I look like a squatter?'" she said she asked him.

During her walk, Mrs. Suits was on a video chat with her husband, who heard the entire interaction with Officer Shaulis.

Mr. Burkett said he was anxious for her.

Advertise with us

"I could tell the change in her voice," he said, as he listened to their exchange.

He told her to keep their call open so he could hear what was happening.

She continued the three- to four-minute walk back to her godmother's home in Wilkinsburg, with Officer Shaulis following her.

When she got to her godmother's house on Collins Road, she walked to the front door and the officer followed her on foot. Mrs. Spencer let her in and the officer stayed on the porch and continued to demand her "information," she said.

She pointed to her luggage, which had her name on it, and Mrs. Spencer also verified Mrs. Suits' identity.

Advertise with us

"Reinforced by her feeling of security from being inside her godmother’s home, Mrs. Suits refused to tender her driver's license to Officer Shaulis," telling him his demands were "unreasonable," the suit says.

She felt that his questioning had no purpose other than to "assert his dominance over Mrs. Suits and to teach her to respect him as a police officer," according to her complaint.

When she refused, she said he entered the home, grabbed Mrs. Suits' wrist and handcuffed her, wrenching her arm behind her back.

"This force was not physically necessary to gain Mrs. Suits’ compliance, but it was for the sole purpose of causing Mrs. Suits to suffer pain as punishment for her disrespect towards his badge," the complaint says.

He "threw her into the back" of his car, according to her suit, and drove to the Churchill station.

Advertise with us

"Officer Shaulis chose to arrest and terrify Mrs. Suits because she failed to 'respect the badge,' not because she engaged in illegal activity of any type," Mr. Hollis wrote in the lawsuit.

As Officer Shaulis entered her godmother's home and handcuffed Mrs. Suits, Mr. Burkett saw it happen through the video chat.

The officer's actions that day, Mr. Burkett said, were "nothing more than [that of] an animal."

Mrs. Spencer said she was standing in the door that evening when her goddaughter got home.

At first, she said, she felt shock and disbelief, followed by anger.

Advertise with us

"How dare he come into my house with no reason, no provocation?" she said.

Mrs. Suits says she suffers from claustrophobia and developed a headache from rising blood pressure. She also said that while in the police car, she had trouble breathing, so she asked for medical help. Inside the police station, she sat handcuffed while the officer demanded her driver's license number and threatened to charge her with resisting arrest and impeding an investigation.

Paramedics came and confirmed her elevated blood pressure.

Mrs. Suits said that when Officer Shaulis put her in his patrol car, God told her to be quiet.

" 'Don't move. Don't do anything that may cause you harm.' "

Advertise with us

She said Officer Shaulis continued to interrogate her. He found an Arkansas address for her and demanded to know why she earlier said she was from Idaho, according to the suit. He also asked about the Georgia address. She said her true address is in Idaho but that her elderly mother for whom she cares is in Georgia and her husband has property in Arkansas.

She said Officer Shaulis told her if she had just "respected" his badge she would have been fine. Instead, she said, he considered taking her Downtown for resisting arrest.

In the end, she said, he told her he would "cut her a huge break" and not take her to jail. She said that before letting her go, Officer Shaulis warned her not to contest any charges he filed and not leave the area.

She went to Forbes Hospital for treatment for muscle spasms, bruising and inflammation, she said.

Three days later, according to the complaint, Officer Shaulis called her and said he was going to charge her with disorderly conduct by summons. She flew back to Georgia the next day. Online court records do not show a citation docketed for Mrs. Suits.

Advertise with us

When Mrs. Suits returned to her godmother's home, and verified with the officer that she was visiting, Mr. Hollis said, the interaction should have been over.

"At that point, any reasonable police officer would have known she wasn't the suspicious person Mrs. Wilson [the 911 caller] thought she was," Mr. Hollis said. "At that point, it should have ended.

"What is wrong with officers in this community? Why is it a black woman can't go on a walk like any other person could?"

Mrs. Suits, who said she serves on a number of boards in Idaho and is active in philanthropy, told the media that she had never had an encounter with the police before.

"It's changed my worldview," she said. "To have this type of encounter, it changes the way I look at things."

Advertise with us

In addition to claims of excessive force, assault, false arrest and other counts against Officer Shaulis, the suit also levels accusations against the borough, saying it has failed to supervise its officers and continues to employ Officer Shaulis despite what Mr. Hollis said is his history of abusing black people.

Officer Shaulis has been sued several times. In the most recent case, he was among a group of defendants sued by students in the Woodland Hills School District in 2017 on federal excessive force claims. Officer Shaulis was a school resource officer at the time. The case was settled last year for $500,000.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com. Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @PaulaReedWard.