Attorneys representing five students who sued the Woodland Hills School District and others in federal court alleging civil rights violations on Tuesday filed motions to settle some of the claims and said the total settlement agreed to was worth more than $500,000.
Separately, on Monday night Churchill council members voted to approve a settlement concerning one of the defendants, former school resource officer Stephen Shaulis.
Officer Shaulis was accused of using excessive force when he knocked out a 14-year-old student’s tooth in an April 2017 incident.
The current and former students sued the district last year, accusing officials of fostering a culture of abuse, including a 2015 incident in which Officer Shaulis was filmed shocking a student with a Taser.
“Each of these students was abused either verbally or physically by individuals with authority over them,” Margaret Coleman, one of the attorneys representing the students, said at the time.
One of the petitions to settle, filed on behalf of a 16-year-old identified as J.H., is for $50,000 and relates to a claim that former principal Kevin Murray assaulted him and threatened to knock out his tooth.
Read More
Another petitioner, identified as D.F., who is also 16, has proposed settling her claims for $150,000. She said in court documents that she was assaulted on two separate occasions, once by Officer Shaulis and another by a security guard working for defendant Dynasty Security. She also claimed that she was falsely charged with crimes that led to her expulsion and incarceration at Shuman Juvenile Detention Center.
Also named as defendants are former Superintendent Alan Johnson and others.
Joseph Luvara, an attorney for the school district, said the agreement does not reflect an admission of guilt on the part of the district or its employees.
"The tentative settlement is in the best interest of all the parties," he said.
A news conference by attorneys Todd Hollis and Timothy O’Brien is scheduled for Wednesday morning to discuss the resolution of the complaint.
“The plaintiffs brought this lawsuit to ensure that society’s most vulnerable members — our children — would never again be subject to a culture of violence and sub-standard education while attending the Woodland Hills School District,” Mr. Hollis said in a news release.
He cited the presence of a new superintendent and principal in the district.
“There is a commitment on their part — and the school district’s — to end the violence and guarantee that no Woodland Hills student is again a victim of the ‘school to prison pipeline,’ “ Mr. Hollis said.
The federal complaint included allegations of physical abuse of students in the school. Mr. Hollis noted that the settlement requires court approval.
Churchill Solicitor Gavin Robb refused to divulge details of the settlement and said he was not present at the council meeting and did not know the vote tally.
___________________
These videos show recent incidents involving students at Woodland Hills High School and school administrators or law enforcement:
Woodland Hills students subdued by police
___________________
Woodland Hills security incidents
___________________
Asked whether there was public discussion of the settlement, which was included on a revised agenda as item No. 3, Mr. Robb said, “I respectfully disagree that settlements of litigation are discussed in public.”
He also said, "The nature of the terms of the settlement were not discussed publicly.”
Melissa Melewsky, media law counsel for the Pennsylvania NewsMedia Association, said: "The Sunshine Act allows certain litigation-related issues to be discussed during a private executive session, but a vote to settle a lawsuit must occur at a public meeting, and the public has a right to weigh in before the vote. The public can’t weigh in if they don’t have any information about what’s being voted on. "
She added that at minimum, the dollar amount of the settlement should have been announced prior to the vote to allow for "meaningful" public comment.
"If council did not announce the basics of the settlement, the public couldn’t possibly offer meaningful comment before the vote, and that’s a Sunshine Act problem because the public’s voice -- or an opportunity for it -- was not part of the process," Ms. Melewsky said.
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.