The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette on Friday challenged the gag order issued by a judge that would prohibit attorneys, law enforcement officers and witnesses from commenting publicly in the case of a man charged with killing an off-duty Pittsburgh police officer in July.

Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Kevin G. Sasinoski filed the order Wednesday, and all attorneys representing Christian Bey — Carmen Robinson, Elbert Gray Jr. and Thomas N. Farrell — consented to it.

The Allegheny County district attorney's office requested the gag order Sept. 10 after Ms. Robinson spoke for nine minutes in an interview with KDKA radio on Aug. 30 — the day of Bey's formal arraignment.

Bey is charged with homicide and other offenses in the July 14 shooting of Officer Calvin Hall on Monticello Street in Homewood.

Advertise with us

The Post-Gazette argues that the order "provides no analysis, rationale, or support for the compelling interest that is protected by prohibiting the free speech of witnesses, whether the threat posed to the protected interest is serious, whether the [order] effectively prevents the harms at which it is aimed, and/or whether the [order] limits no more than necessary to accomplish its goal."

The Post-Gazette calls the order "impermissibly broad" and says it "impermissibly chills free speech as individuals will not be able to determine whether they are in compliance" with the order.